Vergier B, Cany L, Bonnet F, Robert J, de Mascarel A, Coindre J M
Fondation Bergonié, Bordeaux, France.
Br J Cancer. 1993 Dec;68(6):1221-6. doi: 10.1038/bjc.1993.508.
Conflicting reports of MDR1 gene expression in human tumours are observed according to whether studies are performed at the mRNA or P-glycoprotein level. We have investigated this expression in 22 clinically drug-resistant sarcomas at the mRNA level by Northern blot (NB), Dot blot (DB), in situ hybridisation (ISH), and at the protein level by immunohistochemistry (IHC) using three monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs): C219, JSB1, MRK16. Increased MDR1 mRNA expression was detected by NB, DB, and ISH in 1/22 sarcoma (an Ewing's sarcoma). ISH was perfectly correlated with DB hybridisation and confirmed the expression of tumoral cells alone. Specific staining of 100% of tumoral cells was obtained with the three MoAbs in the same sarcoma. Expression in tumoral cells of 12 other sarcomas was detected with MRK16, and positive staining of stromal cells with both C219 (1/22) and MRK16 (8/22) was observed. This study confirms that MDR1 overexpression occurs in human sarcomas but is not the principal mechanism of drug-resistance. Furthermore, positivity with one antibody does not necessarily imply the presence of P glycoprotein (P-gp) and a disparity may exist between the levels of P-gp and its mRNA in the same sample. So care must be taken in interpreting results and more sensitive techniques such as the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) could prove useful.
根据研究是在mRNA水平还是P-糖蛋白水平上进行,关于人类肿瘤中MDR1基因表达的报道相互矛盾。我们通过Northern印迹法(NB)、斑点印迹法(DB)、原位杂交法(ISH)在mRNA水平上,以及使用三种单克隆抗体(MoAbs):C219、JSB1、MRK16通过免疫组织化学(IHC)在蛋白质水平上,对22例临床耐药性肉瘤中的这种表达进行了研究。通过NB、DB和ISH在1/22例肉瘤(尤文肉瘤)中检测到MDR1 mRNA表达增加。ISH与DB杂交完全相关,并证实仅肿瘤细胞有表达。在同一肉瘤中,三种MoAbs对100%的肿瘤细胞进行了特异性染色。在另外12例肉瘤的肿瘤细胞中检测到MRK16的表达,并且观察到C219(1/22)和MRK16(8/22)对基质细胞的阳性染色。这项研究证实MDR1过表达在人类肉瘤中存在,但不是耐药的主要机制。此外,一种抗体呈阳性不一定意味着存在P-糖蛋白(P-gp),并且在同一样本中P-gp及其mRNA水平之间可能存在差异。因此在解释结果时必须谨慎,更敏感的技术如聚合酶链反应(PCR)可能会很有用。