Yeo G T, de Burgh S P, Letton T, Shaw J, Donnelly N, Swinburn M E, Phillips S, Bridges-Webb C, Mant A
Eastern Sydney Health Area Health Service, Prince of Wales Hospital, Randwick, NSW, Australia.
Fam Pract. 1994 Mar;11(1):57-61. doi: 10.1093/fampra/11.1.57.
Public concern about the prescription of hypnosedative drugs (mostly benzodiazepines) led to a controlled trial of an educational intervention to promote rational prescribing by general practitioners (GPs). This paper describes the educational intervention and its process evaluation. In urban and rural New South Wales 137 GPs were visited in office hours by a GP or pharmacist who had undergone communication skills training. Material offered to GPs included relaxation tapes and a booklet of problem-orientated management guidelines. The interview had three stages: rapport was established, then educational material was introduced and finally the visitor sought the doctor's agreement to review five patients on long-term benzodiazepines. The visits were well received. Several measures were composed to reflect doctors' motivation and interest in non-drug management; there was virtually no correlation between any of these process measures and the trial outcome: a change in prescribing behaviour. Self-rating of benzodiazepine prescribing greatly underestimated actual self-reported incidents of prescribing. We interpret this as a reminder that we do not always do what we mean to do, and that we do not always do what we think we do.
公众对催眠镇静药物(主要是苯二氮䓬类药物)处方的关注促使开展了一项对照试验,以评估一项教育干预措施对促进全科医生合理开药的效果。本文描述了该教育干预措施及其过程评估。在新南威尔士州的城乡地区,接受过沟通技巧培训的全科医生或药剂师在工作时间走访了137名全科医生。向全科医生提供的资料包括放松磁带和一本以问题为导向的管理指南手册。走访分为三个阶段:首先建立融洽关系,接着介绍教育资料,最后走访者寻求医生同意对五名长期服用苯二氮䓬类药物的患者进行复查。这些走访受到了广泛欢迎。制定了几项措施来反映医生对非药物治疗的积极性和兴趣;但这些过程指标与试验结果(开药行为的改变)之间几乎没有相关性。对苯二氮䓬类药物处方的自我评估大大低估了实际自我报告的开药事件。我们将此解读为一个提醒,即我们并不总是按照自己的意图行事,也并不总是做我们认为自己做的事情。