Sim E
Unfallkrankenhaus Wien, Vienna, Austria.
J Trauma. 1994 Oct;37(4):525-31.
The position of transcondylar small-caliber drill tunnels after reinsertion of femoral avulsions of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) including avulsions with bone or cartilage fragments, which escape objective verification by conventional roentogenography, was determined in 20 patients by an examination procedure using computed tomography. Coronary tomograms were used for three-dimensional reconstruction of the distal end of the femur and assessment of the position of the perforation sites in the area of the medial aspect of the lateral condyle as well as the distance between them in patients in whom two Kirschner wires had been used (16 patients). A correct position had been achieved only in 4 of the 16 cases with double reinsertion and in one of four cases in which a single Kirschner wire had been used. With exception of one only partially correct placement, localization was found ventrally from the transition line with a predominantly caudally directed component. Assuming a mean thickness of the anterior cruciate ligament of 5 mm, the distance of the drill tunnels in five cases met the anatomic requirements, was too small in six cases, too large in three cases, and could not be evaluated adequately in two cases. The results of the present study illustrate vividly the problems of the surgical technique of Palmer.
采用计算机断层扫描检查程序,对20例患者进行了研究,以确定在前交叉韧带(ACL)股骨撕脱伤再植入后髁间小口径钻孔隧道的位置,这些撕脱伤包括伴有骨或软骨碎片的撕脱伤,而传统X线摄影无法对其进行客观验证。对于使用两根克氏针的患者(16例),采用冠状断层扫描对股骨远端进行三维重建,并评估外侧髁内侧区域穿孔部位的位置以及它们之间的距离。在16例双重再植入病例中,只有4例达到了正确位置;在使用单根克氏针的4例病例中,只有1例达到了正确位置。除了1例仅部分正确放置外,发现定位位于过渡线腹侧,主要向尾侧方向。假设前交叉韧带平均厚度为5mm,5例患者的钻孔隧道距离符合解剖学要求,6例过小,3例过大,2例无法充分评估。本研究结果生动地说明了帕尔默手术技术存在的问题。