Ruch-Ross H S, O'Connor K G
Department of Research, American Academy of Pediatrics, Elk Grove Village, IL 60009-0927.
Pediatrics. 1994 Oct;94(4 Pt 1):508-13.
Concerned about alarmingly low rates of immunization among some young US children as well as disturbing trends in vaccine availability and delivery, the American Academy of Pediatrics sought to examine national trends in referral for immunization among US pediatricians.
A self-administered eight-page questionnaire on issues in childhood immunization was mailed to a random sample of the AAP's 36,000 US resident members. Four rounds of the survey yielded a sample size of 1246, for a response rate of 77%.
A majority of respondents reported referral of some patients for immunization; reported reasons for referral focused on issues of cost to the patient. Personal characteristics of pediatricians (age and gender) were not related to referral practices. Pediatricians practicing in solo or group settings were 2.8 times as likely as those in clinics or other settings to refer patients for immunization. Those in nonmetropolitan areas were nearly twice as likely as those in large metropolitan areas to refer for immunization. When setting and location were controlled, pediatricians who reported that their states had programs to provide all vaccines free or at reduced cost were much less likely to indicate that they referred patients for immunization.
A majority of US pediatricians refer some of their patients to other providers for immunizations because of financial reasons. Children outside of metropolitan areas may be at particular risk for problems of availability of and access to immunizations. This study raises, once again, the issue of differential health care access for children based on payment mechanisms.
鉴于美国一些幼儿的免疫接种率低得惊人,以及疫苗供应和接种方面令人不安的趋势,美国儿科学会试图研究美国儿科医生进行免疫接种转诊的全国趋势。
一份关于儿童免疫接种问题的八页自填式问卷被邮寄给美国儿科学会36000名美国居民会员的随机样本。四轮调查产生了1246个样本量,回复率为77%。
大多数受访者报告曾将一些患者转诊进行免疫接种;报告的转诊原因集中在患者的费用问题上。儿科医生的个人特征(年龄和性别)与转诊做法无关。在单人或团体诊所执业的儿科医生将患者转诊进行免疫接种的可能性是在诊所或其他机构执业的儿科医生的2.8倍。非大都市地区的儿科医生转诊进行免疫接种的可能性几乎是大都市地区儿科医生的两倍。在控制了机构设置和地点后,报告所在州有提供免费或低价所有疫苗项目的儿科医生表示转诊患者进行免疫接种的可能性要小得多。
大多数美国儿科医生因经济原因将一些患者转诊给其他机构进行免疫接种。大都市地区以外的儿童在免疫接种的可及性和获得机会方面可能面临特别的风险。这项研究再次提出了基于支付机制的儿童医疗保健差异问题。