Rice E H, Sombrotto L B, Markowitz J C, Leon A C
Department of Psychiatry, New York Hospital-Cornell Medical Center, Payne Whitney Psychiatric Clinic, New York, White Plains 10605.
Am J Psychiatry. 1994 Nov;151(11):1637-41. doi: 10.1176/ajp.151.11.1637.
Cardiovascular events are the principal cause of medical morbidity in patients receiving ECT. To assess the risks of ECT for individuals with preexisting cardiovascular disease, the authors examined medical complications in older patients treated with ECT during a 1-year period.
A case-control design was used in a review of the charts of 80 consecutive patients who received ECT from August 1990 to August 1991. On the basis of accepted clinical criteria, patients over 50 years of age were divided into two groups: one at increased risk for cardiac complications (N = 26) and one at standard cardiac risk (N = 27). Outcome was measured with a scale designed to assess clinically relevant medical complications.
The risk group was older and had received more medical consultations before ECT than the nonrisk group. Although patients in the risk group were more likely to develop minor complications during ECT, they did not differ significantly from the comparison group in the rate of major complications. No patients died or sustained permanent cardiac morbidity during ECT.
In contrast to a similar study at the same site 15 years earlier, the current study found ECT to be relatively safe in an unselected study group of elderly patients with preexisting cardiac risk factors. The findings underscore the advances in ECT technique over the past 15 years and the importance of identifying and carefully managing patients with cardiac risk factors before and during ECT.
心血管事件是接受电休克治疗(ECT)患者医疗发病的主要原因。为评估ECT对已有心血管疾病个体的风险,作者检查了1年间接受ECT治疗的老年患者的医疗并发症。
采用病例对照设计,回顾了1990年8月至1991年8月连续接受ECT治疗的80例患者的病历。根据公认的临床标准,将50岁以上患者分为两组:一组心脏并发症风险增加(N = 26),另一组心脏风险标准(N = 27)。结果用一个旨在评估临床相关医疗并发症的量表来衡量。
风险组比非风险组年龄更大,ECT前接受的医疗咨询更多。虽然风险组患者在ECT期间更易发生轻微并发症,但在主要并发症发生率上与对照组无显著差异。ECT期间无患者死亡或发生永久性心脏疾病。
与15年前在同一地点进行的类似研究相比,当前研究发现,在一个未经过筛选的、有心脏危险因素的老年患者研究组中,ECT相对安全。这些发现强调了过去15年中ECT技术的进步,以及在ECT前和ECT期间识别并仔细管理有心脏危险因素患者的重要性。