Schoenenberger R A, Heim S M
Department of Medicine, University Hospital, Basle, Switzerland.
BMJ. 1994 Oct 15;309(6960):986-9. doi: 10.1136/bmj.309.6960.986.
To assess the yield of emergency computed tomography of the brain in patients with a first generalised epileptic seizure and to evaluate a four item screening questionnaire on alcohol misuse (CAGE questionnaire) as a triage tool to avoid unnecessary scans in cases of seizures related to withdrawal from alcohol.
Prospective, observational.
Medical casualty unit in a university hospital.
119 adult patients presenting to casualty within one hour of a generalised seizure.
A clinical examination focusing on focal neurological symptoms, the CAGE questionnaire, and computed tomography of the brain with contrast enhancement.
Computed tomography showed a focal, structural lesion of the brain in 40 patients (34% (95% confidence interval 25% to 42%)). In 20 patients (17% (10% to 24%)) an important therapeutic intervention resulted. The presence of a focal neurological deficit had a sensitivity of 50% and a specificity of 89% in predicting focal lesions on computed tomography. Answering "yes" to fewer than two CAGE questions had a sensitivity of 90% and specificity of 44% in identifying patients with focal computed tomography lesions. Focal lesions were not detected on computed tomography in any of the 35 patients (0% (0% to 10%)) who showed no focal neurological symptoms and answered "yes" to two or more CAGE questions.
The diagnostic yield of computed tomography of the brain in adults after a first generalised seizure is high. Combined with the clinical examination, the CAGE questionnaire can reliably identify patients with uncomplicated seizures related to withdrawal from alcohol, in whom computed tomography may not be absolutely necessary.
评估首次全身性癫痫发作患者进行脑部急诊计算机断层扫描的检出率,并评估一份关于酒精滥用的四项筛查问卷(CAGE问卷)作为一种分诊工具,以避免在与酒精戒断相关的癫痫发作病例中进行不必要的扫描。
前瞻性观察性研究。
大学医院的医疗急症科。
119名在全身性癫痫发作后1小时内就诊于急症科的成年患者。
重点关注局灶性神经症状的临床检查、CAGE问卷以及增强对比的脑部计算机断层扫描。
计算机断层扫描显示40例患者(34%(95%置信区间25%至42%))存在脑部局灶性结构性病变。20例患者(17%(10%至24%))因此接受了重要的治疗干预。存在局灶性神经功能缺损在预测计算机断层扫描上的局灶性病变时,敏感性为50%,特异性为89%。对少于两个CAGE问题回答“是”在识别计算机断层扫描有局灶性病变的患者时,敏感性为90%,特异性为44%。在35例无局灶性神经症状且对两个或更多CAGE问题回答“是”的患者中,计算机断层扫描未检测到任何局灶性病变(0%(0%至10%))。
首次全身性癫痫发作后成人脑部计算机断层扫描的诊断检出率很高。结合临床检查,CAGE问卷能够可靠地识别与酒精戒断相关的单纯性癫痫发作患者,对于这些患者,计算机断层扫描可能并非绝对必要。