Naylor A S, Kessing L, Kruse-Larsen C
Department of Psychiatry, Rigshospitalet, Copenhagen, Denmark.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1994 Nov;57(11):1375-81. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.57.11.1375.
The aim was to assess the occurrence and type of psychiatric disorders of patients with medically intractable epilepsy in relation to surgical treatment, with special reference to amygdalohippocampectomy (AHE). The design was a retrospective psychiatric interview study, including Present State Examination (PSE) and diagnostic classification according to the International Classification of Diseases--8th revision (ICD-8) and ICD-10. Forty seven (94% of total) patients operated on between 1987 and mid-1991 in the Danish epilepsy surgery programme were studied. The main group of interest included 37 patients treated by AHE. The presence of psychiatric disorders before and after operation was assessed by PSE (including the Catego classification) and by ordinary clinical procedures, making use of all available information (hospital case notes and presurgical psychiatric assessments independent of the study). Four patients in the AHE group developed depressive disorders of various durations and severity after operation (in three (8%) patients these occurred de novo). One other patient with AHE with a presumed personality disorder who underwent AHE developed a severe depression, as did one patient after a lesionectomy. No patients developed new paranoid hallucinatory psychoses. No association was found between presence of psychiatric disorders and neither right sided cerebral dominance nor histopathological findings. In conclusion, the postoperative psychiatric morbidity in this sample of patients treated with AHE is of the same magnitude as described in recent series of patients undergoing temporal lobe resection for medically intractable epilepsy. Likewise, affective disorders (depressive conditions) constitute the most prominent psychiatric problem after surgery for epilepsy.
目的是评估药物难治性癫痫患者精神障碍的发生率及类型与手术治疗的关系,尤其关注杏仁核海马切除术(AHE)。研究设计为回顾性精神科访谈研究,包括现况检查(PSE)以及依据《国际疾病分类》第8版(ICD - 8)和ICD - 10进行的诊断分类。对1987年至1991年年中丹麦癫痫手术项目中接受手术的47例(占总数的94%)患者进行了研究。主要关注组包括37例接受AHE治疗的患者。通过PSE(包括Catego分类)以及利用所有可用信息(医院病历记录和独立于该研究的术前精神科评估)的常规临床程序评估手术前后精神障碍的存在情况。AHE组中有4例患者术后出现了不同病程和严重程度的抑郁障碍(其中3例(8%)为新发)。另1例患有疑似人格障碍且接受AHE的患者术后出现了严重抑郁,1例接受病灶切除术后的患者也是如此。没有患者出现新的偏执幻觉性精神病。未发现精神障碍的存在与右侧大脑优势或组织病理学发现之间存在关联。总之,在接受AHE治疗的该组患者样本中,术后精神疾病发病率与近期一系列因药物难治性癫痫接受颞叶切除术的患者所描述的发病率相当。同样,情感障碍(抑郁状态)是癫痫手术后最突出的精神问题。