Salmon S E, Crowley J J, Grogan T M, Finley P, Pugh R P, Barlogie B
University of Arizona Cancer Center, Tucson.
J Clin Oncol. 1994 Nov;12(11):2405-14. doi: 10.1200/JCO.1994.12.11.2405.
Standard therapy for multiple myeloma consists of cytotoxic chemotherapy plus glucocorticoids. Interferon (IFN) alfa maintenance is reported to prolong chemotherapy-induced remissions and survival. This study evaluates induction chemotherapy, glucocorticoids, and interferon maintenance in myeloma.
Five hundred twenty-two previously untreated myeloma patients were randomized to three chemotherapy regimens with differing glucocorticoid intensities. Patients who achieved remission were randomized to receive IFN or observation until relapse. Patients who failed to respond to chemotherapy received IFN alfa plus dexamethasone (DEX).
Five hundred nine patients were eligible for induction chemotherapy. Chemotherapy with higher dose-intensity glucocorticoids yielded higher response rates and improved survival (P = .02 for the three-group comparison; P < .05 for each higher glucocorticoid arm v vincristine, melphalan, cyclophosphamide, and prednisone alternating with vincristine, carmustine [BCNU], doxorubicin, and prednisone [VMCP/VBAP]). One hundred ninety-three patients who achieved remission were randomized to receive IFN alfa 3 MU three times weekly or observation. IFN was not superior to observation for relapse-free (P = .95) or overall survival (P = .39) from start of maintenance. Eighty-eight induction failures received 5 MU of IFN three times weekly plus DEX. Patients who received IFN/DEX had a median survival duration of 48 months from start of IFN/DEX.
Higher-dose glucocorticoids increases frequency of response to chemotherapy and prolong survival in myeloma. IFN maintenance with the dose schedule used in this trial did not prolong relapse-free or overall survival. We cannot exclude a small effect of IFN, as most individual trials do not have sufficient statistical power. Meta-analysis of randomized trials evaluating IFN maintenance in myeloma might be of value. While IFN appeared ineffective, addition of higher-dose glucocorticoids improved outcome in myeloma.
多发性骨髓瘤的标准治疗包括细胞毒性化疗加糖皮质激素。据报道,α干扰素维持治疗可延长化疗诱导的缓解期和生存期。本研究评估了骨髓瘤的诱导化疗、糖皮质激素和干扰素维持治疗。
522例既往未接受治疗的骨髓瘤患者被随机分为三种糖皮质激素强度不同的化疗方案。达到缓解的患者被随机分为接受干扰素治疗或观察直至复发。对化疗无反应的患者接受α干扰素加地塞米松(DEX)治疗。
509例患者符合诱导化疗条件。使用高剂量强度糖皮质激素的化疗产生了更高的缓解率并改善了生存期(三组比较P = 0.02;与长春新碱、美法仑、环磷酰胺和泼尼松交替使用长春新碱、卡莫司汀[BCNU]、阿霉素和泼尼松[VMCP/VBAP]相比,每个高剂量糖皮质激素组P < 0.05)。193例达到缓解的患者被随机分为接受每周三次3 MU的α干扰素治疗或观察。从维持治疗开始,干扰素在无复发生存期(P = 0.95)或总生存期(P = 0.39)方面并不优于观察。88例诱导治疗失败的患者接受每周三次5 MU的干扰素加DEX治疗。接受干扰素/DEX治疗的患者从开始使用干扰素/DEX起的中位生存期为48个月。
高剂量糖皮质激素可提高骨髓瘤化疗的缓解频率并延长生存期。本试验中使用的剂量方案的干扰素维持治疗并未延长无复发生存期或总生存期。由于大多数个体试验没有足够的统计效力,我们不能排除干扰素的微小作用。对评估骨髓瘤干扰素维持治疗的随机试验进行荟萃分析可能有价值。虽然干扰素似乎无效,但添加高剂量糖皮质激素可改善骨髓瘤的预后。