Bliss D, Hirschl R, Oldham K, Chey J, Cilley R, Blane C, Olson A, Shulkin B, Coran A
Section of Pediatric Surgery, C.S. Mott Children's Hospital, Ann Arbor, MI 48109-0245.
J Pediatr Surg. 1994 Aug;29(8):1071-4; discussion 1074-5. doi: 10.1016/0022-3468(94)90281-x.
Anterior gastric fundoplication (AGF) has been performed at the University of Michigan since 1988. To objectively evaluate the long-term efficacy of the AGF, the authors performed a study of children who had undergone AGF between June 1988 and June 1990 (n = 46). Six of them died of unrelated causes. Twenty-two consented to follow-up evaluation that included parental interview, physical examination, upper gastrointestinal series (UGI), 24-hour esophageal pH probe monitoring (EpH), and a liquid-phase gastric emptying study. Twenty patients (74%) remained asymptomatic, and only one child required reoperation. Four asymptomatic patients exhibited gastroesophageal reflux (GER) by UGI, and three others by EpH. Three children were noted to have delayed gastric emptying. These results compare favorably with data previously reported from this institution of a 5-year follow-up of children after Nissen fundoplication. There is a trend toward improved efficacy (87% v 74%; P = .12), decreased reoperation rate (4% v 14%; P = .11), and less severe complications. The present study shows that AGF is effective treatment for GER when evaluated by objective studies and is comparable in therapeutic efficacy and safety to the Nissen fundoplication.
自1988年以来,密歇根大学一直在开展胃底折叠术(AGF)。为了客观评估AGF的长期疗效,作者对1988年6月至1990年6月期间接受AGF手术的儿童(n = 46)进行了一项研究。其中6人死于无关原因。22人同意接受随访评估,包括家长访谈、体格检查、上消化道造影(UGI)、24小时食管pH值探头监测(EpH)以及液相胃排空研究。20例患者(74%)仍无症状,只有1名儿童需要再次手术。4例无症状患者经UGI检查显示胃食管反流(GER),另外3例经EpH检查显示有反流。3名儿童被发现有胃排空延迟。这些结果与该机构之前报道的关于儿童尼氏胃底折叠术5年随访的数据相比更有利。在疗效改善(87%对74%;P = 0.12)、再次手术率降低(4%对14%;P = 0.11)以及并发症严重程度减轻方面存在趋势。本研究表明,通过客观研究评估时,AGF是治疗GER的有效方法,其治疗效果和安全性与尼氏胃底折叠术相当。