Khan A J
Department of Pediatrics, Interfaith Medical Center Campus/Meharry Medical College, Brooklyn, New York.
J Natl Med Assoc. 1994 Sep;86(9):690-6.
The role of single-dose therapy was evaluated by pooling data on 320 infants and children included in 12 clinical trials that differed from each other in many variables. Single-dose therapy achieved an overall cure rate of 89%, but varied with different antimicrobial agents. Intramuscular aminoglycosides were the best (cure rate: 96%) closely followed by trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole or a sulfa drug with a cure rate of 90%. The cure rate with amoxicillin (75%) was significantly less. Single-dose therapy was most effective (cure rate: 90%) in well-documented lower urinary tract infections (UTIs) and slightly less effective (cure rate: 89%) among those in whom upper UTI could not be excluded. In patients with a normal urinary tract, single-dose therapy was significantly more effective (cure rate: 93%) than in the group of 36 patients with a urinary tract malformation (cure rate: 69%). Single-dose therapy can be used with confidence in patients with lower UTIs and in those with normal urinary tracts. In patients with abnormal urinary tracts and lower UTIs, single-dose therapy may be used with caution, preferably using aminoglycosides. Further studies are required to establish a definitive role of single-dose therapy in patients with urinary tract malformation.
通过汇总12项临床试验中纳入的320例婴幼儿和儿童的数据,评估了单剂量疗法的作用。这些试验在许多变量方面彼此不同。单剂量疗法的总体治愈率为89%,但因抗菌药物不同而有所差异。肌内注射氨基糖苷类药物效果最佳(治愈率:96%),其次是甲氧苄啶-磺胺甲恶唑或磺胺类药物,治愈率为90%。阿莫西林的治愈率(75%)明显较低。单剂量疗法在记录完善的下尿路感染(UTIs)中最有效(治愈率:90%),在不能排除上尿路感染的患者中效果稍差(治愈率:89%)。在尿路正常的患者中,单剂量疗法明显比36例尿路畸形患者组更有效(治愈率:93% vs 69%)。单剂量疗法可放心用于下尿路感染患者和尿路正常的患者。对于尿路异常和下尿路感染的患者,单剂量疗法可谨慎使用,最好使用氨基糖苷类药物。需要进一步研究以确定单剂量疗法在尿路畸形患者中的明确作用。