Taytard A, Touron D, Lorioux D, Masson F, Vernejoux J M, Tunon De Lara J M
Service des Maladies Respiratoires, Hôpital du Haut-Lévêque, Centre Hospitalo-Universitaire de Bordeaux, Pessac.
Rev Mal Respir. 1994;11(4):385-91.
The consensus conference of the French Language Society of Infectious Disease convened at Lille in 1991 stressed the fact that "in the management of pneumonia, neither the clinical features nor the bacteriological information would enable a prediction of the responsible and effective agent with sufficient accuracy" and that antibiotic therapy should be empirical, based on the probabilities linked to the epidemiology and locality. The object of this study was to ascertain the diagnosis and therapeutic attitude of the general practitioner (GP) dealing with an acute infectious pneumonia in a 40 year old adult, previously well without any critical signs, which was the model taken for the consensus conference. One hundred GPs were selected at random from the general medical list in the city of Bordeaux and registered with the local medical council in Gironde. They were invited to answer a questionnaire containing 69 questions. The results were analysed for the two phases of the enquiry. The strategy of first intention and the method of re-evaluating for treatment instituted. Secondly the strategy used when faced with a patient who did not improve with the initial treatment. Eighty eight GPs answered the questionnaire and thus we are able to give the following information: the differential diagnosis was not clearly made between bronchial and pulmonary pathology when faced with a lower respiratory tract infection; two thirds of the GPs had a diagnostic and therapeutic approach which was in agreement with the recommendations of the consensus.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
1991年在里尔召开的法语传染病学会共识会议强调,“在肺炎的治疗中,临床特征和细菌学信息都无法足够准确地预测致病和有效的病原体”,抗生素治疗应基于与流行病学和地区相关的概率进行经验性治疗。本研究的目的是确定处理一名40岁成年急性感染性肺炎患者的全科医生(GP)的诊断和治疗态度,该患者此前健康且无任何危急体征,这是共识会议采用的模型。从波尔多市的普通医疗名单中随机挑选了100名全科医生,并在吉伦特省当地医疗委员会注册。他们被邀请回答一份包含69个问题的问卷。对调查的两个阶段的结果进行了分析。一是初始治疗的策略以及对所采用治疗进行重新评估的方法。二是面对初始治疗无效的患者时所采用的策略。88名全科医生回答了问卷,因此我们能够提供以下信息:面对下呼吸道感染时,支气管和肺部病变之间的鉴别诊断并不明确;三分之二的全科医生的诊断和治疗方法与共识建议一致。(摘要截选至250词)