Chan C K, Tng T H, Hägg U, Cooke M S
Department of Children's Dentistry and Orthodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, University of Hong Kong.
Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 1994 Nov;106(5):487-95. doi: 10.1016/S0889-5406(94)70071-0.
An experimental cephalometric study on the accuracy of independently locating eight landmarks and the subsequent effects on the maxillary (ILs/NL) and mandibular (ILi/ML) incisor angulation was carried out on 30 dry skulls. The true location of each landmark was marked with a steel ball glued onto the skulls. Two additional steel balls were used as reference markers. A purpose-designed skullholder was made to assure a firm and reproducible positioning of the skulls in the cephalostat. Six series of cephalograms were recorded. One reference series with all the steel balls, four series each with a single steel ball marker removed, one at a time, from each jaw and one series with all the steel ball markers removed, except the reference markers. The combined method error in relocating and replacing the steel ball markers, repositioning the skulls into the skull holder, and digitizing, was low. From the first series, the true position of the palatal plane (NL), the maxillary incisor line (ILs), the mandibular plane (ML) and the mandibular incisor line (ILi) were assessed. From series 2 to 5, each of the landmarks without the steel ball markers was estimated. The accuracy of each landmark was then assessed relative to the true cephalometric plane and its perpendicular. On average, the accuracy was high for all the landmarks except posterior nasal spine (PNS), which was estimated 1.2 mm too far anteriorly (p < 0.05). The standard deviations of the accuracy of the dental and skeletal landmarks were similar, being 1.4 to 2.4 mm. The maxillary incisors were proclined 1.1 degrees (p < 0.05) by the estimates of incision superior (Is).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
对30个干燥颅骨进行了一项实验性头影测量研究,以评估独立定位八个标志点的准确性以及对上下颌切牙角度(上颌:ILs/NL;下颌:ILi/ML)的后续影响。每个标志点的真实位置通过粘贴在颅骨上的钢珠进行标记。另外使用两个钢珠作为参考标记。制作了一个专门设计的颅骨固定器,以确保颅骨在头颅定位仪中稳定且可重复定位。记录了六组头影测量片。一组为带有所有钢珠的参考系列,四组分别从每个颌骨上一次移除一个钢珠标记,还有一组移除所有钢珠标记,仅保留参考标记。在重新定位和更换钢珠标记、将颅骨重新放入颅骨固定器以及数字化过程中的综合方法误差较低。从第一组中评估了腭平面(NL)、上颌切牙线(ILs)、下颌平面(ML)和下颌切牙线(ILi)的真实位置。从第2组到第5组,对没有钢珠标记的每个标志点进行估计。然后相对于真实的头影测量平面及其垂线评估每个标志点的准确性。除了后鼻棘(PNS)向前估计偏差1.2毫米(p < 0.05)外,所有标志点的平均准确性都较高。牙齿和骨骼标志点准确性的标准差相似,为1.4至2.4毫米。通过切牙上点(Is)的估计,上颌切牙前倾1.1度(p < 0.05)。(摘要截断于250字)