Zannad F, Gosse P, Bernard-Fernier M F, de La Garoullaye A
Hôpital Central, Nancy.
Presse Med. 1994 Oct 1;23(29):1335-8.
Since conversion enzyme inhibitors and calcium inhibitors may have synergic actions, we evaluated the antihypertensive effect and tolerance of prolonged-release diltiazem (300 mg/d) and enalapril (20 mg/d).
A double blind study included 176 patients with mild to moderate hypertension. Diltiazem was given to 89 (44 males, 45 females, mean age 49.91 +/- 10.50 years, mean resting diastolic arterial pressure 103 +/- 5 mmHg) and 87 (49 males, 38 females, mean age 51.37 +/- 12.13 years, mean resting diastolic arterial pressure 103 +/- 5 mmHg) received enalapril. Single drug therapy was given for 6 weeks and then continued for another 8 weeks in responders. At the end of the first 6-week period non-responders were given a combination regimen (diltiazem 300 mg and enalapril 20 mg).
After 6 weeks of single drug therapy, 48 patients in the diltiazem group (61.5%) and 53 in the enalapril group (65.4%) had normal blood pressures which remained normal at the end of the trial 8 weeks later in 36 (76%) and 42 (82%) respectively. After 8 weeks of combined regimen 15 of the 24 non-responders (68%) to single drug diltiazem therapy had normal blood pressures as did 18 of the 23 non-responders (78%) to enalapril alone. Tolerance evaluated clinically, biologically and electrocardiographically was comparable to reports in the literature.
Delayed prolonged-release diltiazem 300 mg and enalapril 20 mg thus had equivalent antihypertensive effects and were equally well tolerated. Combination therapy increased effectiveness without inducing any additional side effects.
由于转换酶抑制剂和钙拮抗剂可能具有协同作用,我们评估了缓释地尔硫䓬(300毫克/天)和依那普利(20毫克/天)的降压效果及耐受性。
一项双盲研究纳入了176例轻至中度高血压患者。89例(44例男性,45例女性,平均年龄49.91±10.50岁,平均静息舒张压103±5毫米汞柱)服用地尔硫䓬,87例(49例男性,38例女性,平均年龄51.37±12.13岁,平均静息舒张压103±5毫米汞柱)服用依那普利。单药治疗6周,对有反应者再持续治疗8周。在最初6周结束时,无反应者给予联合治疗方案(地尔硫䓬300毫克和依那普利20毫克)。
单药治疗6周后,地尔硫䓬组48例(61.5%)和依那普利组53例(65.4%)血压正常,8周后试验结束时,分别有36例(76%)和42例(82%)仍保持正常。联合治疗方案治疗8周后,24例单用地尔硫䓬治疗无反应者中有15例(68%)血压正常,23例单用依那普利治疗无反应者中有18例(78%)血压正常。临床、生物学及心电图评估的耐受性与文献报道相当。
300毫克缓释地尔硫䓬和20毫克依那普利具有同等的降压效果,耐受性也相当。联合治疗提高了疗效且未引发任何额外副作用。