Bailey R C, Berg D
Department of Psychiatry and Biobehavioral Sciences, Neuropsychiatric Institute and Hospital, University of California, Los Angeles.
Int J Addict. 1994 Aug;29(10):1315-45. doi: 10.3109/10826089409047946.
Failure in program implementation and related research within closed institutional settings has long been a source of discouragement for correctional administrators and correctional researchers. This paper describes an attempt to implement an innovative treatment program, The Experimental Behavioral and Attitudinal Modification Project, within a civil addict treatment facility to enhance treatment effectiveness. It documents the major obstacles to correctional program innovation and research which ultimately brought about disruption, complacent cooperation, and other implementation problems leading to a project shutdown. It also attempts to place in theoretical perspective the reasons behind implementation failures, particularly as they relate to innovations in treatment and the use of classical experimental designs in closed institutional settings. The article is adapted from the executive summary of the final report to the funding agency. Researchers working to facilitate the effective reintegration of drug-using offenders into society should take heed from this research project, originally implemented in 1970, as a study in FAILURE as apropos today as it was over two decades ago.
在封闭的机构环境中,项目实施及相关研究的失败长期以来一直令惩教管理人员和惩教研究人员感到沮丧。本文描述了在一个民事成瘾者治疗机构内尝试实施一项创新治疗项目——“实验性行为与态度改变项目”,以提高治疗效果。它记录了惩教项目创新与研究面临的主要障碍,这些障碍最终导致了项目中断、消极合作以及其他实施问题,致使项目终止。文章还试图从理论角度阐述实施失败背后的原因,特别是与治疗创新以及在封闭机构环境中使用经典实验设计相关的原因。本文改编自提交给资助机构的最终报告的执行摘要。致力于促进吸毒罪犯有效重新融入社会的研究人员应从这个始于1970年的研究项目中吸取教训,因为它作为一项关于失败的研究,在二十多年前以及如今都同样具有借鉴意义。