Naguib M, Yaksh T L
Anesthesia Research Laboratory, University of California, San Diego 92093-0818.
Anesthesiology. 1994 Jun;80(6):1338-48. doi: 10.1097/00000542-199406000-00022.
Spinal cholinergic receptors have been shown to have a potent antinociceptive action, an effect that can be mimicked by spinal cholinesterase inhibitors. We (1) characterized the cholinergic receptor system through which intrathecally applied cholinesterase inhibitors produce their antinociceptive effect and (2) examined their interaction with spinal mu opioid and alpha 2-adrenergic receptors.
Rats were prepared with chronic intrathecal catheters and the nociceptive threshold was assessed by the use of the radiant heat-evoked hind paw withdrawal.
Spinal administration of neostigmine, edrophonium, carbachol, clonidine, and morphine produced a dose-dependent increase on the thermally evoked hind paw withdrawal latency. The order of potency (dose producing a 50% effect, in nanomoles) was morphine (1.1) = neostigmine (1.2) > clonidine (4.4) > carbachol (15) >> edrophonium (112). Spinal pretreatment with atropine (35 nmol) attenuated the antinociceptive effect of intrathecal carbachol (55 nmol), neostigmine (15 nmol), and edrophonium (500 nmol) but did not affect the potency of intrathecal morphine (15 nmol) or clonidine (435 nmol). In addition, intrathecal pretreatment with naloxone (31 nmol) and yohimbine (28 nmol) attenuated the effects of intrathecally administered morphine and clonidine, respectively, but did not significantly affect the potency of carbachol, neostigmine, or edrophonium. The nicotinic receptor antagonist mecamylamine (60 nmol) did not affect thermal nociception. Isobolographic analysis revealed a synergistic interaction after the coadministration of neostigmine-clonidine (P < 0.001), edrophonium-clonidine (P < 0.0001), and edrophonium-morphine (P < 0.01) mixtures. Neostigmine-morphine exhibited simple additivity.
These data indicate that analgesia after spinal cholinesterase inhibition is mediated through muscarinic, but not nicotinic cholinergic, opioid, or alpha 2-adrenergic receptor systems, and that these spinal effects of cholinesterase inhibition interact synergistically with the antinociceptive effects of intrathecal mu and alpha 2 agonists.
脊髓胆碱能受体已被证明具有强大的抗伤害感受作用,脊髓胆碱酯酶抑制剂可模拟这一效应。我们(1)确定了鞘内应用胆碱酯酶抑制剂产生抗伤害感受作用所通过的胆碱能受体系统,(2)研究了它们与脊髓μ阿片受体和α2肾上腺素能受体的相互作用。
给大鼠植入慢性鞘内导管,通过辐射热诱发后爪回缩来评估伤害感受阈值。
鞘内注射新斯的明、依酚氯铵、卡巴胆碱、可乐定和吗啡可使热诱发后爪回缩潜伏期剂量依赖性增加。效能顺序(产生50%效应的剂量,以纳摩尔计)为吗啡(1.1) = 新斯的明(1.2) > 可乐定(4.4) > 卡巴胆碱(15) >> 依酚氯铵(112)。鞘内预先注射阿托品(35纳摩尔)可减弱鞘内注射卡巴胆碱(55纳摩尔)、新斯的明(15纳摩尔)和依酚氯铵(500纳摩尔)的抗伤害感受作用,但不影响鞘内注射吗啡(15纳摩尔)或可乐定(435纳摩尔)的效能。此外,鞘内预先注射纳洛酮(31纳摩尔)和育亨宾(28纳摩尔)分别减弱了鞘内注射吗啡和可乐定的作用,但对卡巴胆碱、新斯的明或依酚氯铵的效能无显著影响。烟碱受体拮抗剂美加明(60纳摩尔)不影响热伤害感受。等效应线分析显示,新斯的明 - 可乐定(P < 0.001)、依酚氯铵 - 可乐定(P < 0.0001)和依酚氯铵 - 吗啡(P < 0.01)混合物联合给药后存在协同相互作用。新斯的明 - 吗啡表现为简单相加作用。
这些数据表明,脊髓胆碱酯酶抑制后的镇痛作用是通过毒蕈碱型而非烟碱型胆碱能、阿片或α2肾上腺素能受体系统介导的,并且胆碱酯酶抑制的这些脊髓效应与鞘内μ和α2激动剂的抗伤害感受作用存在协同相互作用。