Garibaldi R A, Trontell M C, Waxman H, Holbrook J H, Kanya D T, Khoshbin S, Thompson J, Casey M, Subhiyah R G, Davidoff F
University of Connecticut Health Center, Farmington.
Ann Intern Med. 1994 Jul 15;121(2):117-23. doi: 10.7326/0003-4819-121-2-199407150-00008.
The In-Training Examination in Internal Medicine (ITE-IM) has been offered to internal medicine trainees annually since 1988 as an instrument for self-assessment. This report outlines the manner in which the test is prepared, reviews the results of annual examinations, and analyzes trends during the past 6 years.
Results of each examination were reviewed with regard to the demographic characteristics of persons taking the test, their previous medical training, and their present program affiliations.
Then number of residents participating in the ITE-IM has increased steadily over the past 6 years. In 1993, more than 12,000 residents from more than 90% of internal medicine training programs in the United States participated in the examination; the percentage of international medical school graduates taking the examination increased from 27% in 1988 to 47% in 1993. Statistical analyses of each examination have shown it to be reliable, internally consistent, and discriminating. Over the past 6 years, graduates of U.S. medical schools have scored consistently higher than those of international medical schools and schools of osteopathic medicine on all annual examinations. However, in 1993, for residents at all levels of training, the differences in scores between graduates of U.S. medical schools and graduates of international medical schools narrowed substantially. From 1988 to 1993, there has been a trend toward lower scores by every cohort on each subsequent examination. The decreases in scores are most pronounced for graduates of U.S. medical school and those of schools of osteopathic medicine. The lower scores may be caused by either an increased level of difficulty in the examination or decreased knowledge among examinees.
The ITE-IM is a useful instrument to assess the knowledge base of residents and program directors with a reliable evaluation of themselves and their programs in comparison to their national peer groups. It also provides objective data to monitor trends over time in residents' scores and relates them to the changing demographic characteristics of trainees and to innovations in the clinical curricula of internal medicine training programs.
自1988年起,内科住院医师培训考试(ITE-IM)每年为内科住院医师提供,作为一种自我评估工具。本报告概述了该考试的命题方式,回顾了年度考试结果,并分析了过去6年的趋势。
针对参加考试人员的人口统计学特征、既往医学培训经历以及当前所属培训项目,对每次考试结果进行了评估。
在过去6年中,参加ITE-IM考试的住院医师人数稳步增加。1993年,来自美国90%以上内科培训项目的12000多名住院医师参加了考试;参加考试的国际医学院毕业生比例从1988年的27%增至1993年的47%。对每次考试的统计分析表明,该考试可靠、内部一致且具有区分度。在过去6年的所有年度考试中,美国医学院毕业生的成绩一直高于国际医学院和整骨医学院的毕业生。然而,1993年,对于所有培训阶段的住院医师而言,美国医学院毕业生与国际医学院毕业生的成绩差距大幅缩小。从1988年到1993年,每个队列在后续每次考试中的成绩都呈下降趋势。美国医学院毕业生和整骨医学院毕业生的成绩下降最为明显。成绩下降可能是由于考试难度增加或考生知识水平下降所致。
ITE-IM是一种有用的工具,可用于评估住院医师和项目主任的知识基础,使他们能够与全国同行群体进行可靠的自我评估和项目评估。它还提供客观数据,以监测住院医师成绩随时间的变化趋势,并将这些趋势与学员不断变化的人口统计学特征以及内科培训项目临床课程的创新联系起来。