Halloran M E, Cochi S L, Lieu T A, Wharton M, Fehrs L
Division of Biostatistics, Emory University School of Public Health, Atlanta, GA 30329.
Am J Epidemiol. 1994 Jul 15;140(2):81-104. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a117238.
The authors studied the effects of routine varicella immunization of US preschool children and of implementation of a catch-up program in older children on the age distribution of cases and on overall morbidity, with emphasis on the sensitivity of the results to level of vaccine coverage, duration of protection, responsiveness to boosting, relative residual susceptibility and infectiousness, and degree of morbidity among vaccine breakthrough cases. An age-structured theoretical transmission model was used, with values for vaccine efficacy based on a review of the literature by an expert panel. Although implementation of a vaccination program resulted in a shift in the age distribution of remaining varicella cases toward older ages with higher complication rates, the overall reduction in cases resulted in decreased morbidity as measured by overall number of hospitalizations and number of primary cases. Routine immunization with live-virus varicella vaccine would probably result in a substantial reduction in the number of uncomplicated primary cases of chickenpox, as well as a decreased number of complicated cases requiring hospitalization. The number and age distribution of vaccinated cases would depend strongly on the characteristics of the vaccine. Vaccine efficacy studies in the field should be designed to obtain better estimates of residual susceptibility, residual infectiousness, duration of protection, and effects of boosting by wild-type reinfection.
作者研究了美国学龄前儿童常规水痘免疫以及大龄儿童实施补种计划对病例年龄分布和总体发病率的影响,重点关注结果对疫苗接种覆盖率、保护期、加强免疫反应性、相对残余易感性和传染性以及疫苗突破病例中发病程度的敏感性。使用了一个年龄结构理论传播模型,疫苗效力值基于专家小组对文献的综述。尽管实施疫苗接种计划导致剩余水痘病例的年龄分布向并发症发生率更高的大龄人群转移,但通过住院总数和原发病例数衡量,病例总数的减少导致发病率降低。用减毒活水痘疫苗进行常规免疫可能会大幅减少水痘无并发症原发病例的数量,以及需要住院治疗的并发症病例数量。接种疫苗病例的数量和年龄分布将在很大程度上取决于疫苗的特性。应设计现场疫苗效力研究,以更好地估计残余易感性、残余传染性、保护期以及野生型再感染加强免疫的效果。