Shelbourne K D, Porter D A, Rozzi W
Methodist Sports Medicine Center, Indianapolis, Indiana.
Am J Sports Med. 1994 May-Jun;22(3):318-23. doi: 10.1177/036354659402200304.
Forty patients underwent 45 modified Elmslie-Trillat realignment procedures (mean followup, 2 years) for refractory patellar instability (34 knees) or painful patellofemoral syndrome with malalignment (11 knees). The postoperative congruence angle (mean, +3.4 degrees) was significantly improved compared with the preoperative value (mean, +21.5 degrees). We considered the "normal" congruence angle average as -8 degrees (range, -20 degrees to +4 degrees). Over time postoperatively, we detected no statistical difference in the congruence angle (5 months, 3.4 degrees; 24 months, 6.3 degrees). There were no patellar dislocations postoperatively. Nine knees (20%) had some postoperative subluxation. Ninety-four percent of the patients without subluxation had congruence angles less than 15 degrees, whereas 54% of patients with postoperative subluxation had postoperative congruence angles greater than 15 degrees. The evidence in this study population indicates that the modified Elmslie-Trillat procedure can predictably improve the patellar congruence angle. Adequate correction may eliminate patellar dislocation. Correction of the congruence angle to less than +15 degrees will result in a decreased incidence of postoperative patellar instability. Early full activity postoperatively did not affect the modified Elmslie-Trillat correction of the congruence angle being maintained over time.
40例患者接受了45次改良Elmslie-Trillat复位手术(平均随访2年),治疗难治性髌骨不稳定(34膝)或伴有对线不良的疼痛性髌股关节综合征(11膝)。术后的适合角(平均+3.4°)与术前值(平均+21.5°)相比有显著改善。我们将“正常”适合角平均值视为-8°(范围为-20°至+4°)。术后随访期间,我们未检测到适合角有统计学差异(5个月时为3.4°;24个月时为6.3°)。术后无髌骨脱位发生。9膝(20%)术后有一定程度的半脱位。无半脱位的患者中94%的适合角小于15°,而术后有半脱位的患者中54%的术后适合角大于15°。该研究人群的证据表明,改良Elmslie-Trillat手术可预期地改善髌骨适合角。充分矫正可能消除髌骨脱位。将适合角矫正至小于+15°将降低术后髌骨不稳定的发生率。术后早期完全活动并不影响改良Elmslie-Trillat手术对适合角的矫正效果随时间维持。