Perola M, Vuori E, Penttilä A
Department of Forensic Medicine, University of Helsinki, Finland.
Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 1994 Apr;18(2):255-60. doi: 10.1111/j.1530-0277.1994.tb00010.x.
Alcoholism is known to be greatly underdiagnosed in death certificates, a fact that biases in estimates of alcohol-related mortality. An autopsy series of 1658 cases (920 with natural cause of death and 738 nonnatural) was reviewed to evaluate the extent of this bias, and also to see how well different sources of information served as indicators of alcoholism when alcohol-related disease diagnosed at autopsy was considered as a gold standard. A stepwise logistic regression model adjusted by age and sex showed police reports of individual's alcohol usage and blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of > 2.9/1000 at autopsy to be the two most significant predictors of chronic alcohol abuse (p < 0.0001). The specificities of these two parameters as predictors of chronic alcohol abuse were generally high and sensitivities low. The authors see high BAC (> 2.9/1000), due to its high specificity, as particularly suggestive of chronic heavy drinking. However, it is wise to use these parameters only as an aid in decision-making, not as sole indicators of alcoholism. Deaths associated with chronic heavy drinking were frequent, 50.5% of the total series (male 56.4%, female 37.1%). For all but one age-group (male 45-64 years), however, death certificates mentioned alcohol-related diseases in less than half of these cases. Especially evident underdiagnosis was found for female and males 65 years and older. These results indicate that alcoholism is frequent in such a highly selected population as a series of forensic autopsies and suggest that estimates of prevalence of alcoholism based only on review of death certificates are to be considered with great caution.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
众所周知,酒精中毒在死亡证明中的诊断严重不足,这一事实导致了与酒精相关死亡率估计的偏差。回顾了一个包含1658例病例的尸检系列(920例自然死亡病例和738例非自然死亡病例),以评估这种偏差的程度,并在将尸检诊断的酒精相关疾病视为金标准的情况下,观察不同信息来源作为酒精中毒指标的效果如何。经年龄和性别调整的逐步逻辑回归模型显示,警方报告的个人饮酒情况以及尸检时血液酒精浓度(BAC)>2.9/1000是慢性酒精滥用的两个最显著预测因素(p<0.0001)。这两个参数作为慢性酒精滥用预测指标的特异性普遍较高,而敏感性较低。作者认为,由于其高特异性,高BAC(>2.9/1000)特别提示慢性重度饮酒。然而,明智的做法是仅将这些参数用作决策辅助,而非酒精中毒的唯一指标。与慢性重度饮酒相关的死亡很常见,占总系列的50.5%(男性56.4%,女性37.1%)。然而,除了一个年龄组(男性45 - 64岁)外,在所有其他年龄组中,死亡证明提及这些病例中不到一半的酒精相关疾病。65岁及以上的女性和男性的漏诊尤为明显。这些结果表明,在一系列法医尸检这样高度特定的人群中,酒精中毒很常见,并提示仅基于死亡证明审查的酒精中毒患病率估计应极其谨慎地看待。(摘要截断于250字)