Goupille P, Cotty P, Fouquet B, Alison D, Laffont J, Valat J P
Service de Rhumatologie, CHU Trousseau, Tours.
Rev Rhum Ed Fr. 1993 Nov 30;60(11):791-6.
The facet syndrome seems to be a common cause of low back pain. Percutaneous radiofrequency lumbar facet denervation, developed by Shealy, may be of therapeutic value in facet syndrome patients. This method consists in thermocoagulation of the middle branch of the dorsal primary ramus of the spinal nerve. The authors report their experience with this technique in a retrospective series of 103 patients with chronic low back pain ascribed to facet syndrome. Results were evaluated after 6 and 24 months using a questionnaire and the Stauffer and Coventry classification. Among the 86 patients who completed the questionnaire, 38.4% considered the treatment successful, whereas 61.6% considered that it had not been of benefit. According to the Stauffer and Coventry classification, there were 20.9% excellent results, 22.1% fair results, and 57% failures. Results were better in those patients with a negative history for surgical discectomy. Success rates reported in the literature vary widely, from 14% to 76%. Interpretation of these data is difficult since studies used a broad range of treatment techniques, evaluation methods, and patient selection criteria. A prospective study using stringent inclusion criteria and appropriate evaluation criteria taking quality of life into account is needed to determine the role of percutaneous facet denervation among other treatment options available to low back pain patients.
小关节综合征似乎是下腰痛的常见原因。由谢利研发的经皮射频腰椎小关节去神经术,对小关节综合征患者可能具有治疗价值。该方法包括对脊神经后支中间支进行热凝。作者报告了他们在一组103例归因于小关节综合征的慢性下腰痛患者中应用此技术的经验。在6个月和24个月后使用问卷以及斯托弗和考文垂分类法对结果进行评估。在完成问卷的86例患者中,38.4%认为治疗成功,而61.6%认为治疗无效。根据斯托弗和考文垂分类法,结果为优的占20.9%,尚可的占22.1%,失败的占57%。既往无椎间盘切除术史的患者结果更好。文献报道的成功率差异很大,从14%到76%不等。由于研究采用了广泛的治疗技术、评估方法和患者选择标准,因此对这些数据的解读很困难。需要进行一项前瞻性研究,采用严格的纳入标准和适当的评估标准,并考虑生活质量,以确定经皮小关节去神经术在腰痛患者可用的其他治疗选择中的作用。