Young P C, Shyr Y, Schork M A
Department of Pediatrics, University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City 84132.
Pediatrics. 1994 Sep;94(3):284-90.
To determine the roles of primary care physicians and specialists in the medical care of children with serious heart disease.
Pediatric Cardiology Division; Tertiary Care Children's Hospital.
Convenience sample of parents, primary care physicians, and pediatric cardiologists of 92 children with serious heart disease.
Questionnaire study; questionnaires based on 16 medical care needs, encompassing basic primary care services, care specific to the child's heart disease and general issues related to chronic illness.
All children had a primary care physician (PCP), and both they and the parents (P) reported high utilization of PCP for basic primary care services. However, there was little involvement of PCP in providing care for virtually any aspect of the child's heart disease. Parents expressed a low level of confidence in the ability of PCP in general or their child's own PCP to meet many of their child's medical care needs. Both PCP and pediatric cardiologists (PC) were significantly more likely than parents to see a role for PCP in providing for care specific to the heart disease as well as more general issues related to chronic illness. PC and PCP generally agreed about the role PCP should play, although PC saw a bigger role for PCP in providing advice about the child's activity than PCP themselves did. PC were less likely to see the PCP as able to follow the child for long term complications than PCP did. PC were more likely than PCP to believe that PCP were too busy or were inadequately reimbursed to care for children with serious heart disease. Only about one-third of parents reported discussing psychosocial, family, economic, or genetic issues with any provider, and PCP were rarely involved in these aspects of chronic illness.
Primary care physicians do not take an active role in managing either the condition-specific or the more general aspects of this serious chronic childhood illness. With appropriate information and support from their specialist colleagues primary care physicians could provide much of the care for this group of children. Generalists and specialists are both responsible for educating and influencing parents about the role primary care physicians can play in caring for children with serious chronic illness.
确定初级保健医生和专科医生在患有严重心脏病儿童的医疗护理中所起的作用。
儿科心脏病科;三级护理儿童医院。
对92名患有严重心脏病儿童的家长、初级保健医生和儿科心脏病专家进行便利抽样。
问卷调查研究;基于16项医疗护理需求设计问卷,涵盖基本初级保健服务、针对儿童心脏病的护理以及与慢性病相关的一般问题。
所有儿童都有一名初级保健医生(PCP),他们和家长都报告说在基本初级保健服务方面对初级保健医生的利用率很高。然而,初级保健医生几乎没有参与到儿童心脏病任何方面的护理中。家长们对初级保健医生总体上或自己孩子的初级保健医生满足孩子许多医疗护理需求的能力信心不足。初级保健医生和儿科心脏病专家(PC)比家长更倾向于认为初级保健医生在提供针对心脏病的护理以及与慢性病相关的更一般问题方面应发挥作用。儿科心脏病专家和初级保健医生总体上对初级保健医生应发挥的作用看法一致,不过儿科心脏病专家认为初级保健医生在就孩子的活动提供建议方面应发挥比初级保健医生自己认为的更大作用。与初级保健医生相比,儿科心脏病专家不太认为初级保健医生能够长期跟踪孩子的并发症情况。与初级保健医生相比,儿科心脏病专家更倾向于认为初级保健医生太忙或报酬不足而无法照顾患有严重心脏病的儿童。只有约三分之一的家长报告说与任何医疗服务提供者讨论过心理社会、家庭、经济或遗传问题,初级保健医生很少参与慢性病的这些方面。
初级保健医生在管理这种严重的儿童慢性疾病的特定病情或更一般方面没有发挥积极作用。在专科同事的适当信息和支持下,初级保健医生可以为这组儿童提供大部分护理。全科医生和专科医生都有责任教育并影响家长了解初级保健医生在照顾患有严重慢性疾病儿童方面可以发挥的作用。