McConnell E E, Swenberg J A
School of Public Health, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill.
IARC Sci Publ. 1993(127):323-33.
Fourteen long-term toxicity studies were reviewed in an effort to evaluate the potential carcinogenic activity of styrene and styrene oxide in animals. Each study was reviewed and evaluated for detail and adequacy of design, adequacy of reported data and interpretation. The results of the review are: 1. There is no convincing evidence for a carcinogenic action of styrene in animals, even though it has been studied in several species and by several routes of exposure: inhalation, gavage, in the drinking-water and by intraperitoneal and subcutaneous injection. Most of the studies of styrene, however, have deficiencies in design and/or conduct. 2. Styrene oxide was carcinogenic to the forestomach of rats and mice of each sex after exposure by gavage at all doses tested, including one as low as 50 mg/kg per day. An increase in the incidence of liver neoplasms was observed in male mice in one study. No carcinogenic activity was observed in mice exposed by skin painting. The relevance to humans of the studies in which exposure was by gavage is limited because: (i) the route is less than ideal for extrapolating to human risk from exposure by inhalation or dermally; (ii) xenobiotics often cause neoplasms at this site when given at high concentrations; and (iii) neoplasms at sites distant from the site of exposure were found in only one sex of one species. 3. None of the studies of styrene or styrene oxide reported here is well suited for extrapolating to potential carcinogenic activity in humans, because all have deficiencies in design, conduct and/or interpretation. An up-to-date chronic inhalation study would have to be conducted in order to evaluate this aspect of hazard assessment.
为评估苯乙烯和氧化苯乙烯在动物体内的潜在致癌活性,对14项长期毒性研究进行了综述。对每项研究的设计细节与充分性、报告数据的充分性以及解读进行了审查和评估。综述结果如下:1. 尽管已在多个物种中通过多种暴露途径(吸入、灌胃、饮用水中、腹腔注射和皮下注射)对苯乙烯进行了研究,但没有令人信服的证据表明苯乙烯在动物中有致癌作用。然而,大多数苯乙烯研究在设计和/或实施方面存在缺陷。2. 在所有测试剂量下,包括低至每天50毫克/千克的剂量,经灌胃暴露后,氧化苯乙烯对各性别大鼠和小鼠的前胃具有致癌性。在一项研究中,雄性小鼠肝脏肿瘤的发生率有所增加。通过皮肤涂抹暴露的小鼠未观察到致癌活性。经灌胃暴露的研究与人类的相关性有限,原因如下:(i) 该途径不太适合从吸入或皮肤暴露外推至人类风险;(ii) 当高浓度给予外源性物质时,它们常在该部位引发肿瘤;(iii) 在仅一个物种的一个性别中发现了远离暴露部位的肿瘤。3. 此处报道的苯乙烯或氧化苯乙烯的研究均不太适合外推至人类的潜在致癌活性,因为所有研究在设计、实施和/或解读方面都存在缺陷。为评估危害评估的这一方面,必须进行一项最新的慢性吸入研究。