Greiner N, Nunno V J
Professional School of Psychology, San Francisco, California 94115.
J Clin Psychol. 1994 May;50(3):415-29. doi: 10.1002/1097-4679(199405)50:3<415::aid-jclp2270500313>3.0.co;2-m.
Sixteen Nuremberg war criminals' (NWC) Rorschach records were compared to those of Antisocial Personality Disordered (APD) incarcerated males procured by Gacono and Meloy (1988). The Meloy (1988) set of hypotheses for psychopathy was applied to the NWCs' Rorschachs. The NWCs did not match Meloy's hypotheses, and neither did the antisocial personality disordered inmates. However, individually and as a group, the NWC Rorschach variables indicated less psychopathy, according to the hypotheses, than those of the APD inmates. Unlike most previous studies, variance in type and degree of psychopathology precluded the application of a mental disorder, character structure, or trait to all, or to the majority, of NWCs. Nevertheless, common features, such as avoidance of responsibility, low self-esteem, and capacity for affection, were revealed.
将16名纽伦堡战犯(NWC)的罗夏墨迹测验记录与加科诺和梅洛伊(1988年)获取的反社会人格障碍(APD)男性在押人员的记录进行了比较。梅洛伊(1988年)关于精神病态的一组假设被应用于纽伦堡战犯的罗夏墨迹测验记录。纽伦堡战犯不符合梅洛伊的假设,反社会人格障碍在押人员也不符合。然而,根据这些假设,纽伦堡战犯罗夏墨迹测验变量单独来看以及作为一个群体来看,显示出的精神病态程度都低于反社会人格障碍在押人员。与大多数先前的研究不同,精神病理学类型和程度的差异使得无法将一种精神障碍、性格结构或特质应用于所有或大多数纽伦堡战犯。尽管如此,还是揭示出了一些共同特征,比如逃避责任、自卑和有爱的能力。