Lang R M, DiBianco R, Broderick G T, Gottlieb S S, Kostis J, Lyle P A, Makris L, Rajfer S I, Rucinska E J
Department of Medicine, University of Chicago Medical Center, IL 60637.
Am Heart J. 1994 Sep;128(3):551-6. doi: 10.1016/0002-8703(94)90631-9.
Significant decreases in blood pressure (BP) may occur when administration of angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors is initiated for the treatment of heart failure. The purpose of this study was to compare the safety and tolerability of recommended initial doses of the longer-acting ACE inhibitor enalapril (ENAL) with those of the shorter-acting captopril (CAP) in patients with heart failure who were treated concomitantly with digitalis and diuretic agents. We evaluated BP, serum ACE activity, and clinical status when a low, first dose of ENAL (2.5 mg, n = 59) or CAP (6.25 mg, n = 58) was administered in a double-blind, randomized, and parallel fashion to 117 patients with mild to moderate heart failure. BP and serum ACE activity were measured at 30 min and hourly for 8 hours after drug administration. BP decreases were similar for both groups (mean supine BP -6.2/-4.8 mm Hg for ENAL vs -8.3/-6.4 mm Hg for CAP; mean standing BP -9.2/-5.6 mm Hg for ENAL vs -10.0/-4.7 mm Hg for CAP). Although the maximum mean decrease in BP occurred at hours 4 and 5 in the ENAL group and hours 1 and 2 in the CAP group, considerable between-group overlap was observed for individual patients. Decreases in mean serum ACE activity occurred earlier and were of shorter duration in the CAP group. ENAL significantly inhibited serum ACE activity to a greater extent than did CAP at all time points except the 1st hour. Administration of a first dose of ENAL, 2.5 mg or CAP, 6.25 mg to patients with heart failure was well tolerated.
在开始使用血管紧张素转换酶(ACE)抑制剂治疗心力衰竭时,血压(BP)可能会显著下降。本研究的目的是比较长效ACE抑制剂依那普利(ENAL)与短效卡托普利(CAP)推荐初始剂量在同时接受洋地黄和利尿剂治疗的心力衰竭患者中的安全性和耐受性。我们以双盲、随机和平行方式,对117例轻至中度心力衰竭患者给予低剂量的初始ENAL(2.5mg,n = 59)或CAP(6.25mg,n = 58),并评估血压、血清ACE活性和临床状态。给药后30分钟及之后每小时测量8小时的血压和血清ACE活性。两组的血压下降情况相似(ENAL组平均仰卧位血压-6.2/-4.8mmHg,CAP组为-8.3/-6.4mmHg;ENAL组平均站立位血压-9.2/-5.6mmHg,CAP组为-10.0/-4.7mmHg)。虽然ENAL组血压最大平均下降出现在第4和5小时,CAP组出现在第1和2小时,但个体患者的组间差异有相当大的重叠。CAP组平均血清ACE活性下降出现得更早且持续时间更短。除第1小时外,ENAL在所有时间点对血清ACE活性的抑制作用均显著大于CAP。对心力衰竭患者给予2.5mg的初始ENAL或6.25mg的CAP耐受性良好。