André B, Dansereau J, Labelle H
Département de génie mécanique, Ecole Polytechnique, Montréal (Québec), Canada.
J Biomech. 1994 Aug;27(8):1023-35. doi: 10.1016/0021-9290(94)90219-4.
This paper presents a method to determine the stereoradiographic planes and anatomical vertebral landmarks giving the most reliable three-dimensional reconstructions of the thoracic and lumbar spine for clinical studies. The present investigation was limited to stereoradiographic setups with a normal vertical stereo base. Possible X-ray tube positions are thus corresponding to angles ranging from 0 (conventional posteroanterior radiograph) up to 30 degrees (dimension of the X-ray room). An X-ray phantom was used as a specimen from which three-dimensional reconstructions with the direct linear transformation (DLT) algorithm were obtained. Visibility of landmarks located on pedicles, end-plates, transverse and spinous processes was evaluated for the whole thoracic and lumbar spine (T1 to L5). Process landmarks were discarded because their poor visibility on radiographs produced inaccurate three-dimensional reconstructions. Considering the size, shape and orientation of vertebrae, an angle of 20 degrees between the posteroanterior horizontal position and the angled position of the X-ray tube gave optimal results. Landmarks located on pedicles and end-plates produced the most reliable three-dimensional reconstructions of the spine. Pedicles were found to be more reliable landmarks than end-plates. Validation of the technique with reconstructed steel beads reveals three-dimensional errors under 1.0 mm. Since vertebral landmarks were more difficult to identify on radiographs than steel beads, reconstruction results were compared with those obtained with a biplanar orthogonal setup. This shows that three-dimensional errors of 8.0 mm may be expected on actual reconstructions of the spine and errors as large as 15.0 mm may be present on poorly visible landmarks.
本文提出了一种确定立体放射平面和解剖椎体标志的方法,该方法能为临床研究提供最可靠的胸腰椎三维重建。本研究仅限于具有正常垂直立体基线的立体放射成像设置。因此,可能的X射线管位置对应于从0度(传统后前位X线片)到30度(X射线室尺寸)的角度范围。使用X射线体模作为标本,通过直接线性变换(DLT)算法获得三维重建。对整个胸腰椎(T1至L5)椎弓根、终板、横突和棘突上标志的可见性进行了评估。由于棘突标志在X线片上的可见性较差,导致三维重建不准确,因此将其舍弃。考虑到椎体的大小、形状和方向,后前水平位置与X射线管倾斜位置之间20度的角度可得到最佳结果。位于椎弓根和终板上的标志能产生最可靠的脊柱三维重建。结果发现,椎弓根是比终板更可靠的标志。用重建的钢珠对该技术进行验证,结果显示三维误差在1.0毫米以下。由于椎体标志在X线片上比钢珠更难识别,因此将重建结果与双平面正交设置获得的结果进行了比较。这表明,在脊柱的实际重建中,三维误差可能达到8.0毫米,而在可见性较差的标志上,误差可能高达15.0毫米。