Fox S A, Siu A L, Stein J A
Department of Medicine, University of California-Los Angeles.
Arch Intern Med. 1994 Sep 26;154(18):2058-68.
Breast cancer screening rates, especially for mammography, continue to lag for older women, particularly for women older than 65 years.
We investigated the associations of key variables with reported rates of mammography and clinical breast examination in a sample of 972 women older than 50 years; 724 of them were older than 65 years. They were surveyed in late 1990 through 30-minute bilingual telephone interviews.
Although it was hypothesized that race, age, health status, and physician-patient communication variables would influence utilization rates, only the communication variables (and two access variables) significantly predicted a recent mammogram or clinical breast examination. In particular, the style of the communication--the patient's report of the physician's enthusiasm for mammography when it was discussed with women at the office visit--influenced the women's screening behavior significantly. Women who perceived that their physicians had some enthusiasm for mammography were more than four and a half times more likely than women whose physicians had no or little enthusiasm for mammography to have had one within the previous year. Other findings were that about half of the Los Angeles, Calif, women in this study reported a recent mammogram, an increase from the one third who reported one in the previous survey of 1988; a decline in screening was not reported until after age 75 years. About a quarter of the study women, on the other hand, had never been screened despite the long-standing recommendation for regular screening of women older than 50 years and the risk of breast cancer increasing with age. Surprisingly, women at higher risk of breast cancer were not being screened any more systematically than women at lower risk.
We conclude that improved physician-patient communication skills could be a highly effective and easy-to-learn strategy to increase overall screening rates.
老年女性的乳腺癌筛查率,尤其是乳腺钼靶筛查率,仍然较低,65岁以上女性尤为如此。
我们在972名50岁以上女性样本中调查了关键变量与报告的乳腺钼靶检查率和临床乳腺检查率之间的关联;其中724名年龄超过65岁。1990年末通过30分钟的双语电话访谈对她们进行了调查。
尽管假设种族、年龄、健康状况和医患沟通变量会影响利用率,但只有沟通变量(以及两个获取变量)能显著预测近期的乳腺钼靶检查或临床乳腺检查。特别是沟通方式——患者报告在办公室就诊时与医生讨论乳腺钼靶检查时医生的热情程度——对女性的筛查行为有显著影响。认为医生对乳腺钼靶检查有一定热情的女性,在过去一年接受检查的可能性是认为医生没有或几乎没有热情的女性的四倍半以上。其他发现包括,在这项研究中,加利福尼亚州洛杉矶市约一半的女性报告近期进行了乳腺钼靶检查,较1988年上次调查中报告进行该项检查的三分之一有所增加;直到75岁以后筛查率才出现下降。另一方面,约四分之一的研究女性尽管长期以来一直建议对50岁以上女性进行定期筛查,且乳腺癌风险随年龄增加,但从未接受过筛查。令人惊讶的是,乳腺癌高风险女性接受筛查的系统性并不比低风险女性更高。
我们得出结论,改善医患沟通技巧可能是提高总体筛查率的一种高效且易于学习的策略。