Gale R E, Wheadon H, Goldstone A H, Burnett A K, Linch D C
Department of Haematology, University College London Medical School, UK.
Lancet. 1993 Jan 16;341(8838):138-42. doi: 10.1016/0140-6736(93)90004-z.
Analysis of X-chromosome inactivation patterns in females has been used to assess clonality of various tumours and for prenatal diagnosis of X-linked disorders. Studies with these methods in acute myeloid leukaemia suggest that a significant proportion of cases have clonal remissions (ie, persistence of the malignant clone), which may represent return to a preleukaemic state. We therefore analysed X-chromosome inactivation patterns with differential methylation patterns of heterozygotes for three DNA probes, HPRT, PGK, and M27 beta, in leukaemic patients and normal controls. As expected, blast cells from 67 of 68 analysable samples (99%) were monoclonal or had a skewed X-inactivation pattern. A skewed pattern in remission was also found in 26 of 77 patients (34%), proportion only slightly greater than control (16/75, 21%). In 7 of 10 patients with a skewed pattern in myeloid cells there was similar skewing in the T cells, which is compatible with the concept of a constitutively skewed X-chromosome inactivation pattern of haemopoietic cells in these patients. Our study illustrates the difficulty of interpreting clonality in individual tumour samples and emphasises the importance of comparisons with non-malignant tissue of the same cell type from that individual and from normal control populations.
对女性X染色体失活模式的分析已被用于评估各种肿瘤的克隆性以及X连锁疾病的产前诊断。用这些方法对急性髓系白血病进行的研究表明,相当一部分病例存在克隆性缓解(即恶性克隆的持续存在),这可能代表回到白血病前期状态。因此,我们分析了白血病患者和正常对照中三种DNA探针HPRT、PGK和M27β杂合子的X染色体失活模式及差异甲基化模式。正如预期的那样,68个可分析样本中的67个(99%)的原始细胞是单克隆的或具有偏态的X失活模式。在77例患者中的26例(34%)缓解期也发现了偏态模式,比例仅略高于对照组(16/75,21%)。在10例髓系细胞具有偏态模式的患者中,有7例T细胞也存在类似的偏态,这与这些患者造血细胞中X染色体失活模式持续偏态的概念相符。我们的研究说明了解释单个肿瘤样本中克隆性的困难,并强调了与来自该个体和正常对照人群的相同细胞类型的非恶性组织进行比较的重要性。