Malmberg A B, Yaksh T L
Department of Anesthesiology, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla 92093-0818.
Anesthesiology. 1993 Aug;79(2):270-81. doi: 10.1097/00000542-199308000-00012.
Noxious cutaneous stimuli enhance spinal excitability. The behavioral correlate to this response is found in the rat formalin test, in which formalin injection into the hindpaw evokes signs of nociception (flinching and licking of the injected paw) with acute (phase 1) and delayed-hyperalgesic (phase 2) components.
The effect of intrathecal morphine (a mu agonist), U50488H (a kappa agonist), ST-91 (an alpha 2 agonist), L-PIA (an adenosine A1 agonist), and ketorolac (a nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drug, or NSAID), were examined in rats undergoing the formalin test. Spinal interactions between ketorolac and the mu, kappa, alpha 2, and adenosine A1 agonists were assessed using isobolographic analysis.
Morphine and ST-91 caused a dose-dependent suppression of phase 1 and phase 2 of the formalin test, while U50488H and L-PIA had little effect on phase 1, but caused dose-dependent depression of phase 2. Intrathecal ketorolac inhibited the phase 2 response, but had limited effect on phase 1. The isobolographic analysis revealed a significant synergy (with fractional dose ratios of less than 1) between ketorolac and morphine or ST-91 for phase 1 and phase 2, but only an additive interaction was found between ketorolac and L-PIA or U50488H.
These observations offer systematic support for the powerful interaction between NSAIDs and opioids and certain other analgesics in clinical pain states. These studies also demonstrate that spinal synergy is not a common property of all interactions. Thus, the NSAID synergy appears to occur with agents that exert a concurrent action both pre- and postsynaptic to the primary afferents.
有害的皮肤刺激会增强脊髓兴奋性。在大鼠福尔马林试验中可发现这种反应的行为关联,在该试验中,将福尔马林注射到后爪会引发伤害感受迹象(注射爪的退缩和舔舐),包括急性(第1阶段)和延迟性痛觉过敏(第2阶段)成分。
在进行福尔马林试验的大鼠中,研究了鞘内注射吗啡(一种μ激动剂)、U50488H(一种κ激动剂)、ST - 91(一种α2激动剂)、L - PIA(一种腺苷A1激动剂)和酮咯酸(一种非甾体抗炎药,即NSAID)的作用。使用等效应线图分析法评估酮咯酸与μ、κ、α2和腺苷A1激动剂之间的脊髓相互作用。
吗啡和ST - 91对福尔马林试验的第1阶段和第2阶段产生剂量依赖性抑制,而U50488H和L - PIA对第1阶段影响较小,但对第2阶段产生剂量依赖性抑制。鞘内注射酮咯酸抑制第2阶段反应,但对第1阶段影响有限。等效应线图分析显示,在第1阶段和第2阶段,酮咯酸与吗啡或ST - 91之间存在显著协同作用(分数剂量比小于1),但酮咯酸与L - PIA或U50488H之间仅发现相加作用。
这些观察结果为非甾体抗炎药与阿片类药物以及临床疼痛状态下某些其他镇痛药之间的强大相互作用提供了系统支持。这些研究还表明,脊髓协同作用并非所有相互作用的共同特性。因此,非甾体抗炎药的协同作用似乎发生在对初级传入神经既有突触前又有突触后同时作用的药物之间。