Nilsson L T, Frazén H, Carlsson A S, Onnerfält R
Department of Orthopaedics, University Hospital, Lund, Sweden.
J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1994 Mar;76(2):235-9.
We made a study of 49 total hip arthroplasties at five years, comparing the Charnley hip score, the Nottingham Health Profile (NHP) score and the appearance on serial radiographs. Each of the three investigations was performed by an independent observer with no knowledge of the results of the other two studies. The eight patients with radiographic signs of prosthetic loosening had significant reductions in function and quality of life as measured by the NHP questionnaire, but no differences in the mean Charnley hip scores. None of the eight patients had clinical signs of prosthetic loosening sufficient to recommend revision of their THR. The NHP is a relatively low-cost method of providing long-term follow-up of THR.
我们对49例全髋关节置换术患者进行了为期五年的研究,比较了查恩利髋关节评分、诺丁汉健康状况量表(NHP)评分以及系列X线片表现。三项调查均由独立观察者进行,彼此互不了解其他两项研究的结果。通过NHP问卷测量,8例出现假体松动影像学征象的患者在功能和生活质量方面有显著下降,但查恩利髋关节平均评分无差异。这8例患者均无足以建议翻修其全髋关节置换术的假体松动临床体征。NHP是一种相对低成本的全髋关节置换术长期随访方法。