Redding G M, Hawley E
Department of Psychology, Illinois State University, Normal 61790-4620.
Perception. 1993;22(7):819-28. doi: 10.1068/p220819.
Length judgments were compared for Müller-Lyer stimuli and figures which had line junctions at only one end of the central shaft. A length illusion occurred for fractional figures, only slightly reduced in magnitude from the usual illusion, and the largest reduction occurred for fractional figures with fork junctions. These results are consistent with an hypothesis (drawn from artificial intelligence algorithms for interpreting line drawings) that isolated line junctions are treated as boundary junctions with constrained interpretations of convex and concave edges for the shafts of arrow and fork junctions, respectively. Information about relative position of edges may be used to constrain computation of metric properties and consequential differences in size scaling would be responsible for the illusion. Illusions can arise when information well suited for one kind of task (eg object recognition) is employed in tasks for which it is not well suited (eg size perception).
对缪勒-莱尔刺激图形和仅在中心轴一端有线条连接点的图形进行了长度判断比较。对于分数图形出现了长度错觉,其大小仅比通常的错觉略有减小,而对于带有叉形连接点的分数图形,错觉减小幅度最大。这些结果与一个假设(源自用于解释线条图的人工智能算法)一致,即孤立的线条连接点分别被视为边界连接点,对箭头和叉形连接点的轴的凸边和凹边有受限的解释。关于边缘相对位置的信息可用于限制度量属性的计算,而大小缩放方面的相应差异将导致错觉。当适合一种任务(如物体识别)的信息被用于其不太适合的任务(如大小感知)时,就会产生错觉。