Onwubalili J K, Obineche E N, Assuhaimi S, Bassiouni M
Renal Unit, King Fahad Hospital at AL-Baha, Saudi Arabia.
Transpl Int. 1994;7(1):27-32. doi: 10.1007/BF00335660.
Between October 1985 and November 1991, 16 dialysis patients travelled to Bombay and bought kidneys from living non-related Indian donors for U.S. $7,372. One patient died peri-operatively; one contracted HIV and another hepatitis B virus infections. Six patients are presently positive for hepatitis C virus antibody compared to two cadaver graft recipients (P = 0.03); two of the six patients have chronic active hepatitis. Five-year patient and graft survival rates (75% and 43%, respectively) were similar to those of recipients of 24 cadaver grafts obtained in the United States (67% and 55%, respectively), as was graft function during the first 5 years of follow-up. Graft survival may have improved following commercial kidney transplantation in Bombay, but this practise still poses a risk of dangerous infections and exploitation of donors and recipients. The establishment of a centralized programme of anonymous "rewarded gifting" in countries that cannot eradicate rampant organ commerce may help to expunge exploitation and to ensure uniform, acceptable clinical standards and the safety of patients.
1985年10月至1991年11月期间,16名透析患者前往孟买,从非亲属的印度活体供体处购买肾脏,花费7372美元。1例患者围手术期死亡;1例感染艾滋病毒,另1例感染乙型肝炎病毒。目前,6例患者丙型肝炎病毒抗体呈阳性,相比之下,24例接受尸体肾移植的患者中有2例呈阳性(P = 0.03);6例患者中有2例患有慢性活动性肝炎。患者和移植物的5年生存率(分别为75%和43%)与在美国接受24例尸体肾移植受者的生存率(分别为67%和55%)相似,随访的前5年移植物功能也是如此。孟买商业肾移植后的移植物存活率可能有所提高,但这种做法仍然存在危险感染以及剥削供体和受体的风险。在无法根除猖獗器官交易的国家建立一个集中的匿名“有偿捐赠”计划,可能有助于消除剥削现象,并确保统一、可接受的临床标准以及患者的安全。