Rothrock J F, Hart R G
Department of Neurosciences, University of California, School of Medicine, San Diego 92103-8466.
West J Med. 1994 Jan;160(1):43-7.
Ticlopidine hydrochloride is an antiplatelet agent of proven antithrombotic efficacy that in December 1991 became available for general clinical use in the United States. The relative value of ticlopidine compared with aspirin, also an effective antiplatelet agent, has become a key clinical issue. Whereas ticlopidine is somewhat more effective than aspirin for preventing stroke in certain populations, it is also more expensive and potentially toxic. We recommend its use for patients with threatened stroke who are intolerant of aspirin and for patients who have cerebral ischemic symptoms despite aspirin therapy. Patients surviving major ischemic stroke make up a third group for whom ticlopidine use may be recommended in preference to aspirin. The use of ticlopidine rather than aspirin in patients with other cerebrovascular conditions is not strongly supported by existing data. The risk-benefit-cost equation involving ticlopidine versus other antithrombotic therapies is complex, rendering a wide range of acceptable management practices. If reliable laboratory monitoring for neutropenia during the first 3 months of therapy is not feasible, ticlopidine should not be used.
盐酸噻氯匹定是一种已证实具有抗血栓形成功效的抗血小板药物,于1991年12月在美国开始普遍用于临床。与同样有效的抗血小板药物阿司匹林相比,噻氯匹定的相对价值已成为一个关键的临床问题。虽然在某些人群中,噻氯匹定预防中风的效果比阿司匹林稍好,但它也更昂贵且有潜在毒性。我们建议将其用于对阿司匹林不耐受的有中风风险的患者,以及尽管接受了阿司匹林治疗仍有脑缺血症状的患者。重度缺血性中风幸存者是第三类可能推荐使用噻氯匹定而非阿司匹林的人群。现有数据并不强烈支持在患有其他脑血管疾病的患者中使用噻氯匹定而非阿司匹林。涉及噻氯匹定与其他抗血栓治疗的风险-效益-成本等式很复杂,导致了广泛可接受的管理做法。如果在治疗的前3个月对中性粒细胞减少症进行可靠的实验室监测不可行,则不应使用噻氯匹定。