Noble S, Goa K L
Adis International Limited, Auckland, New Zealand.
Drugs Aging. 1996 Mar;8(3):214-32. doi: 10.2165/00002512-199608030-00006.
Ticlopidine is a thienopyridine derivative which reduces the risk of reversible ischaemia and stroke in patients who have previously experienced a cerebral ischaemic episode. In comparison with aspirin, ticlopidine produced a significant reduction in the risk of stroke in a multicentre clinical trial involving more than 3000 patients with previous transient or persistent minor ischaemia, and was superior to placebo for the prevention of stroke recurrence in more than 1000 patients who had experienced a major thrombotic stroke. The cost-utility ratio for ticlopidine in comparison with aspirin was estimated to be $US31 200 to 55,000 per quality-adjusted life-year gained. Diarrhoea is the most common adverse event in ticlopidine recipients (20 to 22% incidence versus about 10% with placebo), although skin rash, nausea, dyspepsia, bleeding events, abnormal liver function and haematological disturbances were also observed in clinical trials. Severe neutropenia is the most serious event: this developed in 0.85% of patients receiving ticlopidine in 2 large clinical studies (n = 4098) but resolved after treatment withdrawal. Fatal neutropenia, although rare, has been reported in some patients receiving ticlopidine. Thus, ticlopidine is effective in reducing the risk of recurrent cerebral ischaemia and stroke. It appears to provide a gain over aspirin for the prevention of stroke after reversible ischaemia, particularly during the first year of treatment (when the risk of stroke is greatest), although further data on its absolute relative benefit would be useful. The extent to which ticlopidine is prescribed will probably depend on individual clinicians' perception of its risk/benefit and cost-effectiveness profiles. Ticlopidine is likely to be particularly useful for stroke prophylaxis in patients who do not tolerate aspirin or who have an ischaemic episode during aspirin treatment, and for the prevention of stroke recurrence in patients who have previously experienced a major stroke.
噻氯匹定是一种噻吩并吡啶衍生物,可降低既往有脑缺血发作的患者发生可逆性缺血和中风的风险。在一项涉及3000多名既往有短暂性或持续性轻度缺血的患者的多中心临床试验中,与阿司匹林相比,噻氯匹定显著降低了中风风险;在1000多名发生过重大血栓性中风的患者中,噻氯匹定在预防中风复发方面优于安慰剂。与阿司匹林相比,噻氯匹定的成本效益比估计为每获得一个质量调整生命年31200至55000美元。腹泻是接受噻氯匹定治疗的患者中最常见的不良事件(发生率为20%至22%,而安慰剂组约为10%),不过在临床试验中也观察到皮疹、恶心、消化不良、出血事件、肝功能异常和血液学紊乱。严重中性粒细胞减少是最严重的事件:在两项大型临床研究(n = 4098)中,接受噻氯匹定治疗的患者中有0.85%出现了这种情况,但停药后病情缓解。致命性中性粒细胞减少虽然罕见,但在一些接受噻氯匹定治疗的患者中也有报告。因此,噻氯匹定在降低复发性脑缺血和中风风险方面是有效的。在预防可逆性缺血后的中风方面,尤其是在治疗的第一年(中风风险最高时),它似乎比阿司匹林更具优势,不过关于其绝对相对益处的更多数据会很有用。噻氯匹定的处方量可能取决于个别临床医生对其风险/益处和成本效益情况的认知。噻氯匹定可能对不耐受阿司匹林或在阿司匹林治疗期间发生缺血事件的患者预防中风特别有用,也可用于预防既往发生过重大中风的患者中风复发。