Cottraux J, Mollard E, Bouvard M, Marks I
Laboratoire de Psychologie Médicale, Hôpital Neurologique, Lyon, France.
Psychiatry Res. 1993 Oct;49(1):63-75. doi: 10.1016/0165-1781(93)90030-k.
Sixty outpatients with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD, 22 men, 38 women) were randomized to receive 6 months of antiexposure therapy with fluvoxamine (group F), exposure therapy with fluvoxamine (group Fe), or exposure therapy with placebo (group Pe). Patients in group F did not comply with antiexposure therapy, so it was in fact a neutral condition. Patients began with depressed mood (mean Hamilton depression score = 19). Fifty patients were reevaluated at week 8, 44 at week 24 (posttest), 37 at week 48, and 33 at 18 months, 1 year posttreatment (group F, n = 10; group Fe, n = 12; group Pe, n = 11). The three groups improved on rituals and depression. There was a drug effect on rituals at week 8 and on depression at week 24; both these effects disappeared at week 48. The 33 18-month completers had been comparable at baseline to those not followed up, apart from having more severe behavioral avoidance. At 18-month followup, patients as a whole remained improved with no between-group differences; over 80% of the Fe and Pe patients versus 40% of the F patients were not receiving antidepressant treatment (Fe vs. F: p < 0.04; Pe vs. F: p = 0.053; Fe vs. Pe: NS). In OCD fluvoxamine and exposure therapy were synergistic in the short term, and exposure reduced subsequent need for antidepressants in the followup year after they had been stopped.
60名强迫症门诊患者(22名男性,38名女性)被随机分为三组,分别接受为期6个月的氟伏沙明抗暴露疗法(F组)、氟伏沙明暴露疗法(Fe组)或安慰剂暴露疗法(Pe组)。F组患者未遵守抗暴露疗法,因此实际上处于中性状态。患者初始时情绪低落(汉密尔顿抑郁评分均值 = 19)。50名患者在第8周接受重新评估,44名在第24周(后测),37名在第48周,33名在18个月(治疗后1年)接受评估(F组,n = 10;Fe组,n = 12;Pe组,n = 11)。三组在仪式行为和抑郁症状方面均有改善。在第8周时药物对仪式行为有影响,在第24周时对抑郁有影响;这两种影响在第48周时均消失。33名完成18个月治疗的患者在基线时与未接受随访的患者具有可比性,只是行为回避更为严重。在18个月的随访中,患者总体上仍有改善,组间无差异;超过80%的Fe组和Pe组患者不再接受抗抑郁治疗,而F组患者这一比例为40%(Fe组与F组比较:p < 0.04;Pe组与F组比较:p = 0.053;Fe组与Pe组比较:无显著性差异)。在强迫症治疗中,氟伏沙明和暴露疗法在短期内具有协同作用,并且在停药后的随访年中,暴露疗法减少了后续对抗抑郁药物的需求。