Swift G L, Srivastava E D, Stone R, Pullan R D, Newcombe R G, Rhodes J, Wilkinson S, Rhodes P, Roberts G, Lawrie B W
Department of Gastroenterology, University Hospital of Wales, Cardiff.
Gut. 1994 Mar;35(3):363-8. doi: 10.1136/gut.35.3.363.
One hundred and thirty patients with active symptoms of Crohn's disease were treated in a double blind randomised controlled trial with rifampicin, isoniazid, and ethambutol, or identical placebos for up to two years. All other treatment considered necessary was continued. Analyses were based on 126 patients, 63 in each treatment group. Thirty seven in the active and 30 in the placebo group had previous surgical procedures. There was no difference in concomitant treatment between the two groups. Thirty in the active and 46 in the placebo groups were taking corticosteroids at entry to the trial. Forty eight of 63 patients in the active and 49 of 63 in the placebo group, completed at least 12 months' therapy. Reasons for early withdrawal included pregnancy, adverse reaction, and failure to comply. There was no significant difference in the mean number of months completed between the two groups. Nineteen adverse reactions were recorded for 17 patients in the active group compared with three reactions in patients on placebo. All of the nine patients withdrawn early because of adverse reactions were in the active group. Fifteen patients on active treatment and 14 on placebo had surgery during the trial with no difference in the type of surgery required between the groups. Radiological assessments based on 98 patients at the end of the trial showed no significant differences between groups in changes of extent of disease. More patients developed strictures on placebo compared with active treatment but without a statistically significant difference. No differences were found between groups for the total prednisolone dose or the number of days on which prednisolone dose was 10 mg or above. Serial measurements of body weight and Crohn's disease activity index (CDAI) together with blood values for albumin, haemoglobin, white cell count, and platelets showed no consistent different differences between groups. There were occasional significant differences for some of these values between groups, which were not sustained. The trail provides little evidence of tangible benefit from the trail treatment.
130例有克罗恩病活动症状的患者参与了一项双盲随机对照试验,接受利福平、异烟肼和乙胺丁醇治疗,或使用相同的安慰剂,治疗期长达两年。所有其他被认为必要的治疗继续进行。分析基于126例患者,每个治疗组63例。治疗组中有37例、安慰剂组中有30例曾接受过外科手术。两组的伴随治疗无差异。治疗组中有30例、安慰剂组中有46例在试验开始时正在服用皮质类固醇。治疗组63例患者中有48例、安慰剂组63例患者中有49例完成了至少12个月的治疗。提前退出的原因包括怀孕、不良反应和未遵医嘱。两组完成治疗的平均月数无显著差异。治疗组17例患者记录到19例不良反应,而安慰剂组患者记录到3例不良反应。所有因不良反应提前退出的9例患者均在治疗组。15例接受治疗的患者和14例接受安慰剂的患者在试验期间接受了手术,两组所需手术类型无差异。试验结束时基于98例患者的放射学评估显示,两组疾病范围变化无显著差异。与接受治疗相比,安慰剂组更多患者出现狭窄,但无统计学显著差异。两组之间泼尼松龙总剂量或泼尼松龙剂量为10mg或以上的天数无差异。体重、克罗恩病活动指数(CDAI)的系列测量以及白蛋白、血红蛋白、白细胞计数和血小板的血液值显示,两组之间没有一致的差异。这些值在两组之间偶尔存在显著差异,但未持续存在。该试验几乎没有证据表明试验治疗有明显益处。