Tynes T, Jynge H, Vistnes A I
Cancer Registry of Norway, Institute of Epidemiological Cancer Research, Oslo.
Am J Epidemiol. 1994 Apr 1;139(7):645-53. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a117054.
In an attempt to assess whether exposure to electromagnetic fields on Norwegian railways induces brain tumors or leukemia, the authors conducted a nested case-control study of railway workers based on incident cases from the Cancer Registry of Norway in a cohort of 13,030 male Norwegian railway workers who had worked on either electric or non-electric railways. The cohort comprised railway line, outdoor station, and electricity workers. The case series comprised 39 men with brain tumors and 52 men with leukemia (follow-up, 1958-1990). Each case was matched on age with four or five controls selected from the same cohort. The exposure of each study subject to electric and magnetic fields was evaluated from cumulative exposure measures based on present measurements and historical data. Limited information on potential confounders such as creosote, solvents, and herbicides was also collected; information on whether the subject had smoked was obtained by interviews with the subjects or work colleagues. The case-control analysis showed that men employed on electric railways, compared with non-electric ones, had an odds ratio for leukemia of 0.70 (adjusted for smoking) and an odds ratio for brain tumor of 0.87. No significant trend was shown for exposure to either magnetic or electric fields. These results do not support an association between exposure to 16 2/3-Hertz electric or magnetic fields and the risk for leukemia or brain tumors.
为了评估挪威铁路工人接触电磁场是否会诱发脑肿瘤或白血病,作者基于挪威癌症登记处的发病病例,对13030名挪威男性铁路工人(他们曾在电气铁路或非电气铁路工作)进行了一项巢式病例对照研究。该队列包括铁路线路工人、户外车站工人和电力工人。病例组包括39名脑肿瘤男性和52名白血病男性(随访时间为1958 - 1990年)。每个病例按年龄与从同一队列中选取的四至五个对照进行匹配。根据当前测量值和历史数据的累积暴露量度,评估每个研究对象接触电场和磁场的情况。还收集了关于潜在混杂因素(如杂酚油、溶剂和除草剂)的有限信息;通过对研究对象或同事的访谈获取研究对象是否吸烟的信息。病例对照分析表明,与非电气铁路工人相比,电气铁路工人患白血病的比值比为0.70(经吸烟因素调整),患脑肿瘤的比值比为0.87。对于接触磁场或电场,均未显示出显著趋势。这些结果不支持接触16 2/3赫兹电场或磁场与白血病或脑肿瘤风险之间存在关联。