Goetz M B, O'Brien H, Musser J M, Ward J I
Department of Medicine, Sepulveda Veterans Administration Medical Center, California 91343.
Am J Med. 1994 Apr;96(4):342-7. doi: 10.1016/0002-9343(94)90064-7.
The authors evaluated a geographic and temporal cluster of lower respiratory tract infections due to unencapsulated (serologically nontypeable) Haemophilus influenzae to determine whether this event represented the transmission of a single clone.
H influenzae was recovered from eight patients at a nursing home and from three patients in an adjacent acute care hospital. Serotypes, biotypes, outer membrane protein profiles, and multilocus enzyme genotypes were determined to characterize bacterial isolates. Patient records were retrospectively examined to determine clinical and epidemiologic characteristics.
During a 10-day period in September 1991, lower respiratory tract infections caused by H influenzae were diagnosed in four patients residing in a single nursing home unit. Oropharyngeal cultures from four of seven asymptomatic roommates of these patients also grew H influenzae. During the month before and after the nursing home cluster of cases, four other individuals in acute care areas of the hospital had positive sputum cultures for H influenzae. Three of these latter specimens were also available for analysis. All H influenzae isolates were unencapsulated and beta-lactamase-negative. Eight of the nine isolates from the nursing home patients (two morphologically distinct colony types of H influenzae were isolated from one case) had a single outer membrane protein profile arbitrarily designated as X and a single multilocus enzyme genotype arbitrarily designated as A. In contrast, none of the isolates from the acute care cases had this profile (P < or = 0.02; two-tailed Fisher's exact test). The isolates obtained from two of the patients in acute care areas had an outer membrane protein profile arbitrarily designated as Y and a single multilocus enzyme genotype designated as B. These two patients were contemporaneously hospitalized in adjacent intensive care unit cubicles. The remaining isolates displayed an outer membrane protein profile arbitrarily designated as W. All roommates of the four patients in the nursing home were administered oral rifampin 600 mg daily for 4 days. H influenzae was not recovered from follow-up oropharyngeal cultures obtained 1 week after the completion of therapy. No beta-lactamase-negative H influenzae were identified in this unit during the subsequent 9 months.
This study furnishes strong evidence for the nosocomial transmission of a clone of unencapsulated H influenzae in a nursing home unit. Epidemiologic data showed temporal and geographic clustering of respiratory tract infections and colonization by H influenzae. Outer membrane protein profiles and multilocus enzyme genotype analysis indicated that seven of eight patients at the nursing home carried a single clone of unencapsulated H influenzae. Laboratory and epidemiologic data also demonstrated the presence, and possible nosocomial transmission, of a second clone of unencapsulated H influenzae in a physically separate area of the hospital. Finally, although a causal relationship is not proven, the outbreak ended following the administration of rifampin prophylaxis of asymptomatic carriers.
作者评估了因未包膜(血清学不可分型)流感嗜血杆菌引起的下呼吸道感染在地理和时间上的聚集情况,以确定该事件是否代表单一克隆的传播。
从一家疗养院的8名患者以及相邻一家急症护理医院的3名患者中分离出流感嗜血杆菌。测定血清型、生物型、外膜蛋白谱和多位点酶基因型以对细菌分离株进行特征分析。对患者记录进行回顾性检查以确定临床和流行病学特征。
1991年9月的10天期间,在一家疗养院的一个单元中,4名居住患者被诊断为由流感嗜血杆菌引起的下呼吸道感染。这4名患者的7名无症状室友中,有4人的口咽培养物也培养出了流感嗜血杆菌。在疗养院病例聚集之前和之后的那个月,医院急症护理区的另外4人痰培养物中流感嗜血杆菌呈阳性。后3份标本也可供分析。所有流感嗜血杆菌分离株均为未包膜且β-内酰胺酶阴性。疗养院患者的9份分离株中有8份(从1例患者中分离出两种形态不同的流感嗜血杆菌菌落类型)具有一种任意指定为X的单一外膜蛋白谱和一种任意指定为A的单一多位点酶基因型。相比之下,急症护理病例的分离株均无此谱型(P≤0.02;双侧Fisher精确检验)。从急症护理区的2名患者中获得的分离株具有一种任意指定为Y的外膜蛋白谱和一种指定为B的单一多位点酶基因型。这两名患者同时在相邻的重症监护病房小隔间住院。其余分离株显示出一种任意指定为W的外膜蛋白谱。疗养院4名患者的所有室友均每日口服利福平600mg,共4天。治疗完成1周后进行的随访口咽培养物中未培养出流感嗜血杆菌。在随后的9个月中,该单元未发现β-内酰胺酶阴性的流感嗜血杆菌。
本研究为疗养院单元中未包膜流感嗜血杆菌克隆的医院内传播提供了有力证据。流行病学数据显示了流感嗜血杆菌引起的呼吸道感染和定植在时间和地理上的聚集。外膜蛋白谱和多位点酶基因型分析表明,疗养院8名患者中有7名携带单一克隆的未包膜流感嗜血杆菌。实验室和流行病学数据还证明了在医院一个物理上独立的区域存在未包膜流感嗜血杆菌的第二个克隆,并可能存在医院内传播。最后,虽然因果关系未得到证实,但在对无症状携带者进行利福平预防给药后,疫情结束。