Stone S P, Whincup P
Department of Geriatric Medicine, Royal Free Hospital School of Medicine, London.
J R Coll Physicians Lond. 1994 Jan-Feb;28(1):52-8.
To examine the extent to which current guidelines for the hospital management of stroke are being met, a series of 15 specific standards covering initial assessment and management, rehabilitation, discharge and secondary prevention was developed from the guidelines suggested by the King's Fund and the Royal College of Physicians. This article describes these standards, their interobserver agreement on their use in practice. The interobserver agreement on the application of most standards was good (80% or more). A survey of 100 consecutive patients with stroke showed that certain standards were well met (adequate social history, routine investigation, prevention of pressure sores and monitoring of blood pressure), whereas others were poorly met (diagnosis, rapid referral to therapists, functional reassessment, liaison with general practitioners, documentation of multidisciplinary rehabilitation programmes, and communication with patients and relatives). Several standards, especially those central to the rehabilitation process, were met significantly more frequently in patients managed by geriatricians than in those managed by general physicians. This may be attributable to geographical concentration of patients and to rehabilitation led by consultants trained in stroke management. It is suggested that these standards are verifiable measures which can be used more widely to audit the process of care.
为了检验当前中风医院管理指南的符合程度,根据国王基金和皇家内科医师学院建议的指南,制定了一系列涵盖初始评估与管理、康复、出院及二级预防的15项具体标准。本文描述了这些标准,以及它们在实际应用中的观察者间一致性。大多数标准应用的观察者间一致性良好(80%或更高)。对100例连续中风患者的调查显示,某些标准得到了较好的满足(充分的社会史、常规检查、预防压疮和血压监测),而其他标准则满足得较差(诊断、快速转诊至治疗师、功能重新评估、与全科医生联络、多学科康复计划的记录以及与患者及亲属的沟通)。在由老年病科医生管理的患者中,几项标准,尤其是那些对康复过程至关重要的标准,比由普通内科医生管理的患者更频繁地得到满足。这可能归因于患者的地理集中以及由接受过中风管理培训的顾问主导的康复。建议这些标准是可验证的措施,可更广泛地用于审核护理过程。