De Oliveira H G, Rossatto E R, Prolla J C
Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil.
Cytopathology. 1994 Feb;5(1):27-32. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2303.1994.tb00124.x.
Adenosine deaminase (ADA) and lymphocyte proportion are known to be independently elevated in tuberculous effusions, but are non-specific, and false positive results are frequent. To overcome this problem the combined use of both parameters was prospectively studied in 276 patients with pleural effusion seen at Porto Alegre, Brazil. Using a cut-off level of 40 U/l at 37 degrees C (method of Giusti19) for ADA activity and lymphocyte proportion of more than 50%, the correct diagnosis of tuberculosis (sensitivity) was made in 90.7% (CI 87.3-94.1%) of 54 patients. A specificity of 97.7% (CI 95.9-99.5%) was recorded. Five false positive diagnoses of tuberculous effusion were made. Five false negative diagnoses were made: three cases with haematogenous tuberculous dissemination with low ADA levels, and two other patients with low lymphocyte proportion. The combined use of ADA activity determination and lymphocyte proportion is a highly efficient diagnostic strategy of low cost, that merits wider use.
已知腺苷脱氨酶(ADA)和淋巴细胞比例在结核性胸腔积液中会独立升高,但这些指标缺乏特异性,假阳性结果很常见。为解决这一问题,对巴西阿雷格里港收治的276例胸腔积液患者前瞻性地研究了联合使用这两个参数的情况。采用37℃时ADA活性40 U/l的临界值(Giusti19法)以及淋巴细胞比例超过50%的标准,54例患者中有90.7%(95%CI 87.3 - 94.1%)被正确诊断为结核病(敏感性)。特异性为97.7%(95%CI 95.9 - 99.5%)。有5例假阳性诊断为结核性胸腔积液。有5例假阴性诊断:3例血行播散型肺结核患者ADA水平低,另外2例患者淋巴细胞比例低。联合测定ADA活性和淋巴细胞比例是一种高效且低成本的诊断策略,值得更广泛应用。