Wittbrodt E T, Spinler S A
Philadelphia College of Pharmacy and Science, PA 19104.
Ann Pharmacother. 1994 Feb;28(2):236-41. doi: 10.1177/106002809402800215.
To review various pretreatment regimens for the prophylaxis of anaphylactoid reactions to radiographic contrast media (RCM) in high-risk patients. The proposed etiologies and risk factors for such reactions are also reviewed.
A MEDLINE search of the English-language literature was used to identify pertinent human studies and reviews.
All studies comparing pretreatment regimens for anaphylactoid reactions to RCM were reviewed as well as studies comparing the incidence of anaphylactoid reactions between lower and higher osmolar RCM.
The two types of reactions to RCM are dose-independent, unpredictable anaphylactoid (pseudoallergic or idiosyncratic) reactions and the dose-dependent, predictable physicochemical (intrinsic, nonidiosyncratic) reactions. Prophylaxis of the former type is targeted at stemming the effects of certain chemical mediators, primarily histamine. The use of lower osmolar RCM is associated with a lower incidence of anaphylactoid reactions compared with higher osmolar RCM, but is significantly more expensive. Risk factors for such reactions are a history of previous anaphylactoid reaction to RCM, asthma, and reaction to skin allergens or penicillin. Discontinuation of any beta-blockers before the procedure is suggested. Pretesting patients with a small amount of RCM has little predictive value for an anaphylactoid reaction. Various pretreatment prophylactic regimens have been studied. Almost all included a corticosteroid to target the inflammatory response and a histamine1 (H1)-antagonist to blunt the effects of histamine. In some clinical trials, ephedrine was added for bronchodilation and cimetidine for its antagonism at the histamine2-receptor. The few controlled clinical trials that have been performed show the combination of prednisone and diphenhydramine to be most beneficial in preventing anaphylactoid reactions to RCM. The addition of ephedrine or cimetidine to a pretreatment regimen remains controversial.
More controlled clinical studies comparing various pretreatment regimens for high-risk patients need to be performed, especially in patients receiving lower osmolar RCM. Recommendations for high-risk patients who must receive RCM include use of a lower osmolar agent, pretreatment with a corticosteroid and an H1-antagonist, discontinuation of beta-blockers if the patient is taking any, and bedside availability of appropriate medications and equipment to treat anaphylaxis.
回顾针对高危患者预防造影剂(RCM)类过敏反应的各种预处理方案。同时也对这类反应的推测病因及危险因素进行回顾。
通过检索MEDLINE英文文献来识别相关的人体研究及综述。
对所有比较RCM类过敏反应预处理方案的研究以及比较低渗和高渗RCM类过敏反应发生率的研究进行综述。
对RCM的两类反应分别是与剂量无关、不可预测的类过敏(假过敏或特异反应性)反应以及与剂量相关、可预测的物理化学(固有、非特异反应性)反应。对前一种反应的预防旨在阻止某些化学介质(主要是组胺)的作用。与高渗RCM相比,使用低渗RCM类过敏反应的发生率较低,但成本显著更高。这类反应的危险因素包括既往有RCM类过敏反应史、哮喘以及对皮肤过敏原或青霉素过敏。建议在检查前停用任何β受体阻滞剂。用少量RCM对患者进行预测试对类过敏反应几乎没有预测价值。已对各种预处理预防方案进行了研究。几乎所有方案都包括一种针对炎症反应的皮质类固醇和一种抑制组胺作用的组胺1(H1)拮抗剂。在一些临床试验中,添加麻黄碱用于支气管扩张,添加西咪替丁用于其对组胺2受体的拮抗作用。已进行的少数对照临床试验表明,泼尼松和苯海拉明联合使用对预防RCM类过敏反应最为有益。在预处理方案中添加麻黄碱或西咪替丁仍存在争议。
需要进行更多比较高危患者各种预处理方案的对照临床研究,尤其是在接受低渗RCM的患者中。对于必须接受RCM的高危患者的建议包括使用低渗剂、用皮质类固醇和H1拮抗剂进行预处理、如果患者正在服用β受体阻滞剂则停用、以及床边备有治疗过敏反应的适当药物和设备。