Pandurangi A K, Pelonero A L, Nadel L, Calabrese V P
Department of Psychiatry, Medical College of Virginia, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond.
Schizophr Res. 1994 Feb;11(3):245-50. doi: 10.1016/0920-9964(94)90018-3.
We compared five indices of brain structure between two groups of schizophrenics, namely, those with high and normal levels of antibody in the serum to herpes virus. Eleven 'immuno-positive' and 21 'immuno-normal' subjects obtained from a concomitant study of serum IgG antibody to viruses underwent magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) utilizing a 1 Tesla magnet and 8 mm thick slices. We measured ventricle-brain ratio (VBR), 3rd ventricle width, cortical atrophy, area of corpus callosum, and frontal lobe area. The differences between groups were assessed by t-test and chi-square analysis. Eight of 11 immuno-positives compared to 7 of 21 immuno-normals showed evidence of cortical atrophy (chi 2 = 4.49, p < 0.03). The immuno-positives had smaller left frontal area (mean + s.d = 125.69 + 21.30 versus 143.76 + 19.84, t = 2.07, p < 0.05) and larger 2nd quadrant of the corpus callosum (mean + s.d. = 1.58 + 0.39 versus 1.27 + 0.52, t = 2.68, p < 0.01). The right frontal area also was smaller in immuno-positives but not significant. VBR, 3rd ventricle and the 1st, 3rd and 4th callosal quadrants did not differ between the groups. We conclude that high antibody titers to herpes found in the sera of some schizophrenics might reflect an earlier pathogenetic process that affected brain development. Further studies of antibodies in CSF and brain structure in these or similar subjects and those suspected to be exposed to viral infections in utero should be vigorously pursued to obtain definitive evidence for this hypothesis.
我们比较了两组精神分裂症患者的五个脑结构指标,即血清中疱疹病毒抗体水平高的患者和抗体水平正常的患者。从一项关于血清IgG病毒抗体的伴随研究中选取了11名“免疫阳性”和21名“免疫正常”的受试者,使用1特斯拉的磁体和8毫米厚的切片进行磁共振成像(MRI)。我们测量了脑室脑比率(VBR)、第三脑室宽度、皮质萎缩、胼胝体面积和额叶面积。通过t检验和卡方分析评估组间差异。11名免疫阳性者中有8人,相比之下21名免疫正常者中有7人表现出皮质萎缩的迹象(卡方 = 4.49,p < 0.03)。免疫阳性者的左额叶面积较小(均值 + 标准差 = 125.69 + 21.30,而另一组为143.76 + 19.84,t = 2.07,p < 0.05),胼胝体第二象限较大(均值 + 标准差 = 1.58 + 0.39,而另一组为1.27 + 0.52,t = 2.68,p < 0.01)。免疫阳性者的右额叶面积也较小,但不显著。两组之间的VBR、第三脑室以及胼胝体的第一、第三和第四象限没有差异。我们得出结论,一些精神分裂症患者血清中发现的高疱疹抗体滴度可能反映了影响大脑发育的早期致病过程。应大力开展对这些或类似受试者以及怀疑在子宫内接触过病毒感染的受试者的脑脊液抗体和脑结构的进一步研究,以获得该假设的确凿证据。