Miyagami M, Miyagi A, Kido G, Tsubokawa T
Department of Neurological Surgery, Nihon University School of Medicine.
No Shinkei Geka. 1994 May;22(5):421-8.
Authors have studied 128 cases of meningiomas which were operated on and examined histologically. 12 cases (11.3%) of 106 cases of the meningiomas followed up for more than 5 years after surgery had recurrence after the primary operation. The distribution of age and sex, the tumor location, the histological type, the extent of tumor evacuation and AgNORs counts and BrdU labeling index for the evaluation of tumor proliferation were studied comparatively in the two groups, the recurrent and nonrecurrent meningiomas. 8 cases (19.0%) of 42 cases of the meningiomas in the age-group lower than 50 years old were recurrent cases, whereas 4 cases (6.0%) of 67 cases in the age-group over 50 years old were non-recurrent. Concerning the sex distribution of the meningiomas in our cases recurrent rate was 20.5% among males and 6.0% among females. The tumor locations of the meningiomas did not correlate significantly with recurrence. The extent of tumor removal demonstrated Simpson grade I (47 cases), grade II (37 cases), grade III (17 cases), grade IV (5 cases) on primary operation. Recurrence was found in 11 cases (13.1%) of 84 cases operated on by total removal of Simpson grade I or grade II. 8 cases of 11 cases had recurrence within 5 years after the primary operation of Simpson grade I or II. Total removal of the tumor was important in order to bring about long survival after operation. But correlation between the extent of tumor removal and recurrence was not able to be recognized. Histologically, all of the malignant, atypical and papillary type of meningiomas treated in the primary operations had recurrence.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
作者对128例接受手术并进行组织学检查的脑膜瘤病例进行了研究。106例脑膜瘤患者术后随访5年以上,其中12例(11.3%)在初次手术后复发。对复发和未复发的两组脑膜瘤患者,比较研究了年龄、性别分布、肿瘤位置、组织学类型、肿瘤切除范围以及用于评估肿瘤增殖的AgNORs计数和BrdU标记指数。年龄低于50岁的42例脑膜瘤患者中,8例(19.0%)复发,而年龄超过50岁的67例患者中,4例(6.0%)未复发。就我们病例中脑膜瘤的性别分布而言,男性复发率为20.5%,女性为6.0%。脑膜瘤的肿瘤位置与复发无显著相关性。初次手术时肿瘤切除范围显示为辛普森一级(47例)、二级(37例)、三级(17例)、四级(5例)。辛普森一级或二级全切的84例患者中,11例(13.1%)复发。辛普森一级或二级初次手术后,11例中有8例在5年内复发。为实现术后长期生存,肿瘤全切很重要。但肿瘤切除范围与复发之间的相关性无法确定。组织学上,初次手术治疗的所有恶性、非典型和乳头状脑膜瘤均复发。(摘要截选至250字)