Laemmel K
Psychiatrische Klinik, Kantonsspital Luzern.
Schweiz Rundsch Med Prax. 1993 Sep 7;82(36):964-8.
Considering the frequency with which the diagnosis 'psychosomatic illness' is established, it is puzzling how little attention has been paid to its differential diagnosis. The reason for this may be found not only in the difficulties with which that diagnosis is made but also in the doctor's view of the world and his or her understanding of illness in general. If the doctor only believes in what can be measured and weighed as being real, all symptoms for which no identifiable cause can be found must be considered as imaginary and 'all in the patient's head'. Most contemporary theories about the origin of psychosomatic illness are based on Freud's speculations, established at the beginning of this century. The are deeply rooted in the mechanistic, reductionistic and monocausalitic theories typical for his time. They suggested that the metamorphosis from thought-processes to somatic symptoms begin with a rather mysterious 'jump', taking place in the unconscious of the patient and thus remaining unknown to him. Today we know that all illness has a multifactorial basis and does not develop in a straight line but as a cybernetic loop. Psychosocial factors play as much a role as biological ones. Diagnosis by exclusion (no clear physical findings) or through dualistic thinking (the cause must be either psychological or physical) are, after inadequate knowledge of somatic or psychological medicine, the most common source of the erroneous diagnosis of psychosomatic illnesses. To avoid this, a psychosomatic perspective is needed, an outlook which is based on a holistic understanding of man in health and sickness.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
考虑到“身心疾病”这一诊断确立的频率,令人费解的是,人们对其鉴别诊断的关注却如此之少。造成这种情况的原因不仅在于做出该诊断存在困难,还在于医生的世界观以及其对疾病的总体理解。如果医生只相信能够被测量和称重的才是真实的,那么所有找不到可识别病因的症状都必定会被视为想象出来的,“全都是患者脑子里想出来的”。大多数当代关于身心疾病起源的理论都基于弗洛伊德在本世纪初提出的推测。这些理论深深植根于他那个时代典型的机械论、还原论和单因论。它们认为从思维过程到躯体症状的转变始于一种相当神秘的“跳跃”,发生在患者的潜意识中,因此患者自己并不知晓。如今我们知道,所有疾病都有多重因素基础,并非呈直线发展,而是像一个控制论循环那样发展。社会心理因素与生物学因素所起的作用一样大。在对躯体医学或心理医学知识不足的情况下,通过排除法诊断(没有明确的体格检查结果)或二元思维方式(病因必定要么是心理的要么是躯体的)是身心疾病错误诊断最常见的根源。为避免这种情况,需要一种身心医学的视角,一种基于对健康和患病状态下的人进行整体理解的观点。(摘要截选至250词)