Miller D H, Barkhof F, Nauta J J
University Department of Clinical Neurology, National Hospital for Neurology and Neurosurgery, London, UK.
Brain. 1993 Oct;116 ( Pt 5):1077-94. doi: 10.1093/brain/116.5.1077.
There is now widespread agreement that serial brain MRI is useful in monitoring treatments designed to modify the course of multiple sclerosis. It has been less clear whether gadolinium enhancement is needed. We therefore compared the relative sensitivity of long repetition time (TR) spin echo (SE) and gadolinium enhanced short TR SE sequences in detecting active lesions. A blind analysis of the two sequences was performed in 26 untreated patients with early relapsing--remitting (19) or secondary progressive (seven) multiple sclerosis who underwent monthly MRI on four occasions (one baseline and three follow-up). Active lesions were defined as either new or enlarged lesions on long TR SE, or new or persistent enhancing lesions on short TR SE. In one patient there were 144 active lesions, all of which were seen with enhancement on short TR SE, but only 17 were seen on long TR SE. Amongst the remaining 25 cases, a total of 106 active lesions were seen: 68 (64%) were seen only with enhancement on short TR SE, 16 (15%) were seen only on long TR SE, while 22 (21%) were active on both sequences. We conclude that gadolinium enhancement markedly increases the sensitivity of monthly brain MRI in monitoring the treatment of relapsing--remitting or secondary progressive multiple sclerosis. With this frequency of scanning, a post contrast short TR SE sequence is the most sensitive method for detecting active lesions. The smaller yet still substantial incidence of active lesions seen only on the long TR SE sequence suggests that it should also be obtained.
目前人们普遍认为,连续脑部磁共振成像(MRI)对于监测旨在改变多发性硬化病程的治疗方法很有用。钆增强是否必要则不太明确。因此,我们比较了长重复时间(TR)自旋回波(SE)序列和钆增强短TR SE序列在检测活动性病灶方面的相对敏感性。对26例未经治疗的早期复发缓解型(19例)或继发进展型(7例)多发性硬化患者进行了这两种序列的盲法分析,这些患者每月进行4次MRI检查(一次基线检查和三次随访)。活动性病灶定义为长TR SE序列上的新病灶或扩大病灶,或短TR SE序列上的新病灶或持续强化病灶。1例患者有144个活动性病灶,所有这些病灶在短TR SE序列上均表现为强化,但在长TR SE序列上仅见17个。在其余25例中,共发现106个活动性病灶:68个(64%)仅在短TR SE序列上表现为强化,16个(15%)仅在长TR SE序列上可见,22个(21%)在两种序列上均为活动性病灶。我们得出结论,钆增强显著提高了每月脑部MRI监测复发缓解型或继发进展型多发性硬化治疗的敏感性。以这种扫描频率,增强后短TR SE序列是检测活动性病灶最敏感的方法。仅在长TR SE序列上可见的活动性病灶发生率虽小但仍相当可观,这表明也应获取该序列图像。