Levine J, Swartz M, Feibel H, Schreiber G
Abarbanel Mental Hospital, Israel.
Isr J Psychiatry Relat Sci. 1993;30(3):179-82.
Atropine treatment before electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is used for two main reasons: a) to prevent transient post-ictal bradyarrhythmias due to excessive vagal tone; b) to minimize secretions within the respiratory tract. In the present study we have compared the effects of premedication using atropine, a non-selective muscarinic antagonist, with biperiden, an M1-selective muscarinic antagonist. Cardiac rate and other cardiac parameters and respiratory tract secretions after ECT were compared in order to determine whether atropine effects following ECT involve central or peripheral antagonistic effects. Our results show that in preventing excessive sialorrhea following ECT, atropine works antagonistically through peripheral glandular M2 receptors whereas biperiden antagonizing M1 receptors fails to prevent sialorrhea. Our results are not conclusive concerning cardiac protective effects of atropine following ECT. None of the patients, whether premedicated by atropine or biperiden, displayed bradyarrhythmias following ECT. No significant differences were found in any of the measured cardiac parameters following ECT between atropine and biperiden premedications. Thus, the question whether atropine exerts its protective cardiac effects following ECT through central (probably M1) or peripheral M2 receptors remains open.
在电休克治疗(ECT)前使用阿托品主要有两个原因:a)预防由于迷走神经张力过高引起的短暂性发作后缓慢性心律失常;b)尽量减少呼吸道分泌物。在本研究中,我们比较了使用非选择性毒蕈碱拮抗剂阿托品与M1选择性毒蕈碱拮抗剂比哌立登进行术前用药的效果。比较了ECT后的心率及其他心脏参数和呼吸道分泌物,以确定ECT后阿托品的作用是涉及中枢还是外周拮抗作用。我们的结果表明,在预防ECT后过多的流涎方面,阿托品通过外周腺体M2受体起拮抗作用,而拮抗M1受体的比哌立登未能预防流涎。关于ECT后阿托品的心脏保护作用,我们的结果尚无定论。无论是用阿托品还是比哌立登进行术前用药的患者,在ECT后均未出现缓慢性心律失常。在ECT后,阿托品和比哌立登术前用药的任何测量心脏参数均未发现显著差异。因此,阿托品在ECT后是通过中枢(可能是M1)还是外周M2受体发挥其心脏保护作用的问题仍未解决。