Fraenkel Y, Durst R, Ginath Y
Talbieh Mental Health Center, Jerusalem, Israel.
Med Law. 1993;12(3-5):283-6.
The legal status of the mentally impaired has been dealt with in Halachic literature since the third century. This article presents four Halachic viewpoints regarding the exemption of the mentally ill patient from legal responsibility in tort and criminal law: lack of mental awareness; lack of free will; lack of judgment; categorial personal status. Halachic legislations with regard to the liability of the insane predate the criteria as applied by modern psychiatry. The similarities between the Halachic and contemporary medicolegal approaches are presented.
自公元3世纪以来,犹太教律法文献中就已经涉及到精神障碍者的法律地位问题。本文提出了犹太教律法关于精神病患者在侵权法和刑法中免除法律责任的四种观点:缺乏精神意识;缺乏自由意志;缺乏判断力;绝对个人身份。关于精神病人责任的犹太教律法早于现代精神病学所应用的标准。文中还介绍了犹太教律法方法与当代法医学方法之间的相似之处。