Hoffart A, Due-Madsen J, Lande B, Gude T, Bille H, Torgersen S
Research Institute, Modum Bads Nervesanatorium, Vikersund, Norway.
J Clin Psychiatry. 1993 Dec;54(12):481-7.
Both behavior-modification methods and antidepressants have proved to be effective in the treatment of agoraphobia. The authors examined the effects of clomipramine on agoraphobia in patients who failed to respond to exposure-based behavioral treatment.
Eighteen patients with panic disorder with agoraphobia who had not responded to previous inpatient behavioral treatment were recruited to a 12-week, placebo-controlled, double-blind crossover study of clomipramine, at top doses of 150 mg/day for 3 weeks. The patients were assessed on measures of phobic avoidance, agoraphobic cognitions, panic, state and trait anxiety, subjective anxiety, and depression.
One patient dropped out of the study after 6 weeks. On most outcome measures, the 17 study completers had significantly (p < .05) lower symptom scores at posttest in the active drug period than at posttest in the placebo period; however, the clinical gains were modest.
The short-term efficacy of clomipramine for agoraphobic patients who failed to respond lastingly to behavioral treatment was demonstrated. It remains to be shown that clomipramine can lead to clinically significant and lasting benefits in these patients.
行为矫正方法和抗抑郁药已被证明在治疗广场恐怖症方面均有效。作者研究了氯米帕明对那些对基于暴露的行为治疗无反应的广场恐怖症患者的疗效。
招募了18名伴有广场恐怖症的惊恐障碍患者,这些患者之前住院接受行为治疗时无反应,参与一项为期12周的氯米帕明安慰剂对照双盲交叉研究,最高剂量为150毫克/天,持续3周。对患者进行了恐惧回避、广场恐怖认知、惊恐、状态和特质焦虑、主观焦虑及抑郁等方面的评估。
1名患者在6周后退出研究。在大多数结果指标上,17名完成研究的患者在活性药物期的测试后症状评分显著低于安慰剂期的测试后(p <.05);然而,临床改善程度不大。
证明了氯米帕明对那些对行为治疗未能产生持久反应的广场恐怖症患者具有短期疗效。氯米帕明能否在这些患者中带来具有临床意义的持久益处仍有待证明。