Nattrass G R, King G J, McMurtry R Y, Brant R F
Department of Surgery, University of Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1994 Jan;76(1):88-94. doi: 10.2106/00004623-199401000-00011.
Radiographs of the wrist often do not include the entire third metacarpal, so the standard method for measurement of the carpal height ratio (the carpal height divided by the length of the third metacarpal) cannot be used. In this study, the ratio of the carpal height relative to the length of the capitate was evaluated for its suitability as a reproducible alternative. The revised carpal height ratio (the carpal height divided by the capitate length) was evaluated for reproducibility and clinical utility in both in vitro and in vivo studies: it was determined from the radiographs of ten cadaveric wrists; those of 100 wrists (fifty pairs) of normal volunteers, made with controlled positioning; those of 100 wrists, drawn at random from radiographs that had been previously interpreted as showing normal findings; and those of fifty wrists of twenty-nine patients who had documented rheumatoid arthritis. The new ratio was found to be constant in the normal population, consistent bilaterally, decreased in patients who had carpal collapse, and reproducible.
腕部X光片通常不包括完整的第三掌骨,因此无法使用测量腕高比(腕高除以第三掌骨长度)的标准方法。在本研究中,评估了腕高与头状骨长度之比作为一种可重复替代方法的适用性。在体外和体内研究中评估了修订后的腕高比(腕高除以头状骨长度)的可重复性和临床实用性:它由十具尸体手腕的X光片确定;100只手腕(五十对)正常志愿者的X光片,采用控制定位拍摄;从先前解读为显示正常结果的X光片中随机抽取的100只手腕的X光片;以及29名有类风湿性关节炎记录的患者的50只手腕的X光片。发现新的比值在正常人群中是恒定的,双侧一致,在腕骨塌陷的患者中降低,并且具有可重复性。