Gresenguet G, Tevi-Benissan C, Payan C, Pascal B, Matta M, Dragon M A, Belec L
Service de Microbiologie (Virologie), Hôpital Broussais, Paris, France.
Bull Soc Pathol Exot. 1993;86(4):236-42.
The "conventional" algorithm for HIV testing based on the confirmation of all positive anti-HIV screening reactions by Western blot requires sufficient laboratory facilities and is expensive, that limits its use in developing countries, such as in subsaharian Africa. The apparition of second and third generation screening ELISA which are very sensitive and specific, as well as the development of rapid tests which are simple, visually read, and sufficiently sensitive and specific, has permitted the design of "alternative" strategy for HIV testing utilizing the association of 2 ELISA and/or rapid tests, in order to limit the use of a confirmatory assay. Alternative strategies are less expensive, yield generally very high sensitivity and specificity, and have proved to be valuable for African countries. In this study, 5 alternative strategies, using different associations of two second generation screening tests, one classical ELISA (Genelavia mixt) and one rapid test (Test PACK HIV-1/HIV-2 AB) have been retrospectively evaluated in the field in Bangui, Central African Republic, with a panel of 130 sera (prevalence of HIV infection: 42.7%). The strategy using two sequential screening tests (Test Pack HIV-1/HIV-2 AB following by Genelavia mixt) with the confirmation of discordant results by Western blot permitted to diagnose HIV-1 infection in Bangui with a sensitivity, a specificity and a positive predictive value of 100%, and to reduce the cost of more than 50% in comparison with the conventional strategy. Such an alternative strategy could be useful for the individual notification of HIV serology in Bangui.
基于用蛋白质印迹法确认所有抗艾滋病毒筛查阳性反应的“传统”艾滋病毒检测算法需要充足的实验室设施且成本高昂,这限制了其在发展中国家(如撒哈拉以南非洲)的使用。第二代和第三代筛查酶联免疫吸附测定法(ELISA)的出现,它们非常灵敏且特异,以及快速检测方法的发展,这些方法简单、通过肉眼读取且足够灵敏和特异,使得利用两种酶联免疫吸附测定法和/或快速检测方法的组合设计“替代”艾滋病毒检测策略成为可能,以便限制确证检测的使用。替代策略成本较低,通常具有很高的灵敏度和特异性,并且已被证明对非洲国家很有价值。在本研究中,在中非共和国班吉的实地,使用一组130份血清(艾滋病毒感染率:42.7%),回顾性评估了5种替代策略,这些策略使用了两种第二代筛查检测、一种经典酶联免疫吸附测定法(Genelavia mixt)和一种快速检测(Test PACK HIV-1/HIV-2 AB)的不同组合。使用两种连续筛查检测(先进行Test Pack HIV-1/HIV-2 AB检测,随后进行Genelavia mixt检测)并通过蛋白质印迹法确证不一致结果的策略,在班吉诊断艾滋病毒-1感染时,灵敏度、特异性和阳性预测值均为100%,与传统策略相比,成本降低了50%以上。这种替代策略可能对班吉艾滋病毒血清学的个体通报有用。