Bearcroft P W, Small J H, Flower C D
Department of Radiology, Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge.
Clin Radiol. 1994 Jan;49(1):56-8. doi: 10.1016/s0009-9260(05)82916-2.
An intensive programme of guideline development and dissemination is not always practical. We designed general practitioner guidelines for chest radiography and disseminated them to a group of 33 practices selected randomly from the practices that refer more than five patients for chest radiography annually. The subsequent 2500 requests were analysed and demographic data, the referring practice and the relevant history noted. We documented a reduction in the proportion of referrals that were contrary to the guidelines by 30.5% (from 8.2% to 5.7%, P = 0.016), a reduction in referral rate with an inadequate history by 29.7% (from 15.5% to 10.9%, P = 0.0008) and an increase in the frequency that a presumptive diagnosis was stated by 14.5% (from 42.9% to 49.1%, P = 0.0025). There was no overall reduction in referral rate in the study group and the reasons for this are discussed. We conclude that guidelines for chest radiography are effective in reducing inappropriate requests and can also improve the clinical information provided.
制定和传播指南的强化方案并不总是可行的。我们制定了胸部X光检查的全科医生指南,并将其分发给从每年转诊超过五名患者进行胸部X光检查的诊所中随机挑选出的33家诊所。随后对2500份申请进行了分析,并记录了人口统计学数据、转诊诊所及相关病史。我们记录到,不符合指南的转诊比例降低了30.5%(从8.2%降至5.7%,P = 0.016),病史不充分时的转诊率降低了29.7%(从15.5%降至10.9%,P = 0.0008),初步诊断的陈述频率增加了14.5%(从42.9%增至49.1%,P = 0.0025)。研究组的转诊率没有整体下降,对此原因进行了讨论。我们得出结论,胸部X光检查指南在减少不适当的申请方面是有效的,并且还可以改善所提供的临床信息。